The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 2 · February 1906
50printed page
scan 14 of 52
Facsimile · scan 14 of 52
Scan of p. 50
Text · transcribed from the scan

edge is power, that knowledge which permeates the whole man, which, transmuted into thinking and feeling, has become a live and active force. To impose limitations upon oneself does not necessarily lead to narrowness; on the contrary, the more the domain of knowledge to be cultivated is circumscribed, the more intense becomes the power of him who controls it. Here in part lies the explanation of the remarkable influence with which our teachers of medieval days were endowed. Their knowledge was confined within the boundaries of the Talmud and the literature growing out of it; but over that field they ruled absolute. Their knowledge was an integral part of their ego. They mastered it, and it mastered them, and therefore they were able to exercise mastery over others. If they were one-sided, it was with a superb one-sidedness. Knowledge and ability in them were moral forces, because they were not extraneous possessions, they constituted their real life. Their knowledge being a quick force by reason of its intensity, it was invested with creative, vitalizing power, by virtue of which their views spread abroad until they became the common property of the people as a whole. Jewish learning it was that offered full reparation to a scorned, oppressed, and baited people, for all it suffered in the course of tens of centuries; Jewish learning it was that preserved the clearness and energy of intellects which all else conspired to brutalize and deaden. Those who insist that the Talmud promotes scepticism, and therefore have only words of scorn for it, they understand history as little as they understand the Talmud.

The modern theory that the success achieved by a rabbi is in inverse ratio to his knowledge, is correct if success is measured by the amount of his salary. Our whole history, however, is a protest against this theory; it proves at every point that the rabbi attained genuine success whenever the congregation recognized the consummate master in him.

The Bahur who went forth from the Yeshibah to take charge of a congregation sought to realize the ideals he had learned to revere in his teacher, the ideals which possessed the soul of the medieval rabbi, and were expressed, not in well-sounding periods and well-turned phrases, but in acts and deeds. Those ideals may be summed up as an identification of true knowledge with true faith, a faith not merely metaphysical and abstract, but of concrete, effectual content. The Jew of the Middle Ages was convinced that his actions were to be estimated only according to their moral worth, for he was animated by the belief that God does not view with indifference the doings of man, be they good or evil. If the Jew of average standing and intelligence held this belief, it was the distinction of the scholar to verify and apoly it in the walks of everyday life. He recognized but one judge, his own conscience, and therefore he valued his independence beyond all things. This feeling went so far that when changed conditions forced the rabbi to accept remuneration, his principle remained noblesse oblige, and he accepted only the small salary that exactly sufficed for his needs.

It is an interesting fact which has not received adequate attention, that during the Middle Ages the smaller towns were the seats of rabbinical learning. The large city held no attraction for the frugal, modest scholar. What he demanded of his congregation was the possibility of gathering numerous pupils about him, and if that end could be compassed in a small town, so much the better. Congregations regarded it as an honor to have a famous scholar fill the post as their rabbi. They competed with each other for the distinction, holding out to the rabbi as an inducement not an abundant salary, but the promise to maintain a wide circle of Bahurim. No perquisites were attached to the rabbinical office. So late as the fifteenth century the rabbis refused the fees for divorces, which an old ordinance set at a rather high