The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
2printed page
scan 8 of 54
Facsimile · scan 8 of 54
Scan of p. 2
Text · transcribed from the scan

in learning and ability to the contributors, and must understand the tendencies of the age, the nature of the reading public, the faults of the people and their proper remedies. The editor must hold himself responsible for the welfare of his public, and must have the courage to speak his views freely, unmindful of the opposition that may be provoked, and persist until he gets a hearing. He must be awake to all that is going on about him, must be moderate and tactful and must possess the gift of gathering about him a faithful hand of able writers. The contributors, on the other hand, must not be mere phrase-makers, but men of learning and of high purpose, who have ideas and know how to express them. Then the public, on its part, must show its appreciation of the vast labors of the editor and contributors. And if in addition to all these, there be harmony and unity of purpose among the editors of the different journals, the power of the press would be unlimited. Unfortunately, however, Hebrew Journalism has become a prey to ignorance. Men of limited knowledge and narrow views, who are neither gifted by nature nor equipped by training for literary work, are at the helm of journalism. Flattery has become the current coin with which editors pay their contributors, while among the editors themselves there is constant warfare instead of harmony.

"The Holy One, blessed be He"—says the parodist—"saw that if all the editors would stand by one another and counsel one another they might destroy the world with their power of speech, and Israel would turn out a new being. But this generation is not worthy of such an event. What did the Holy One, blessed be He, do? He moved them with hatred towards one another. The Hamaggid prosecutes the Halebanon, and the Halebanon vexes the Hamaggid, both abuse the Hashha-har. The Hamelitz denounces the Hakol, and the Hakol slanders the Hamabit . . . Said He, I will set editor against editor, and they shall fight everyone against his brother, and everyone against his neighbor, their spirit shall fail, and their counsel I will destroy, and Israel shall do what his heart desires."

The result is that Hebrew periodicals abound in trivialities and in personal allusions. Much ink is spilt on riddles and chronograms,

and much labor wasted on empty rhymes and pedantic annotations. It is sickening to see the amount of rubbish issuing from the Hebrew press. Such is his severe judgment of the periodical literature of twenty-five years ago, and such his reasons for their weak hold upon the people.

But Brill's attention was not centered on journalism alone. His critical view embraced general literature as well, and it is significant that he noticed a spirit of discontent in the camp of literary men of the day. Contrasting our literary work of two or three generations before, Brill finds his much superior. Yet his predecessors were thoroughly satisfied with their work, while his contemporaries were not with theirs. This shows that the feeling of discontent in literature had become a general complaint. Gordon's lament: "For Whom Do I Work?" uttered a decade before, had by that time become the common cry of men of letters. The old idea that Hebrew was to serve as a medium for European thought, as a stepping-stone to universal culture, had lost its meaning for that generation, because it no longer needed any medium—at least they thought so—and the more modern idea, the one developed and promulgated by the national movement of recent years, that the maintenance of Hebrew as a living literature was necessary for the maintenance of the national consciousness in the Jew, this idea had not yet taken deep root in the heart of Jewish men of letters. Both authors and readers were just then groping for some ideal for which life would be worth living, and not finding it, struck out in a note of discontent and disappointment.

Occasionally Brill aims his sarcasm at otherphases of Jewish life. The meanness of thefalse benefactors, the extortion of the physicians, the oppression of the collectors, theuncleanliness in synagogues and elementaryHebrew schools, all these are subjects of histrenchant satire. But he is most bitter againstthe class of rabbis who do nothing but quarrelamong themselves, heap one superstitious lawupon another, and live and wax fat by thesweat of other people. Again he returns toliterature, and lashes both the immoderatecritic as well as the cowardly author. Andinterwoven in this whole satiric web runs a