The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
21printed page
scan 27 of 54
Facsimile · scan 27 of 54
Scan of p. 21
Text · transcribed from the scan

By Abram Lipsky, A. M.

Imitative Jews

It is very unlikely that any reader of THE MACCABEAN placed a Christmas tree in his or her home during the holiday season just past, when so many beautiful trees were offered for sale at every grocery and meat-market. We have heard of Jews of such broad tolerance for the customs of their neighbors that they had no scruples about lighting up a tree,—for the amusement of their children. We are quite confident that those Jews were not Zionists. Perhaps they themselves would find it rather hard to tell what sort of Jews they are.

Whose Symbol is it.

But what harm is there in setting up a Christmas tree? There really isn't any. It is only a matter of taste. Some people like to act blindly, imitating others without understanding the meaning of their action. Other people are satisfied to follow a crowd wherever the crowd goes. It is enough for them that they are not alone, that someone else is leading, that they are doing what the majority of people are doing. The fact is the Christmas tree might just as reasonably be adopted as a symbol by Jews as by Christians. It originally belonged to the ancient Teutons of Europe before Christianity was known to them. It represents life, and the lights that are kindled upon it represent the fire of the sun. And the whole thing was meant to symbolize the return of the sun from his winter decline,—the return of light and life. Now, if one feels inclined to celebrate these events by means of the true symbol, it isn't such a serious matter. But there is something repellant about a frivolous and ignorant imitation of the old pagan rite,—merely because the tree with its lighted candles "looks pretty."

Practice vs. Ideal

THE return of each year of Christmas Day with its church services, its anthems, its talks about peace and good-will, the giving of presents, the kindness to the poor, brings out in strong contrast the violence that is actually being practiced by the nations. This year there is bloody revolution, massacre and fraternal strife in Russia; last year there was the war with Japan; and the year before that there was the English war against the Boers, the American war with the Filipinos, the American war with Spain, the trouble with China, and so on. Every year the ministers of the Christian nations preach about peace and good-will, the choirs sing beautiful anthems, the congregations feel kindly towards all mankind,—and the nations keep on fighting or getting ready to fight. Is all the Christmas sentiment wasted? Is it all in vain? It is hard, of course, to tell what would be the state of affairs if nobody talked about "peace on earth, good-will toward men." It seems likely, however, that there would be even more fighting than there is now. There is no reason to suppose that there would be less. And, if we could imagine churches and choirs and congregations on Christmas Day preaching, singing and revelling in the opposite sentiment—war on earth, ill-will between men,—it might appear that the Christmas sentiment with which we are familiar is not altogether in vain, even though the practice of the nations is so sadly below the Christmas ideal.

The Ideal of Peace ia Isaiah

Most of us know that the ideal of peace and good-will is not an exclusively Christian ideal. "How beautiful upon the mountains