"presses one with the sense that it must be "poor, perishable stuff, without roots that "take lasting hold in the minds of men; "while any instance of complete comprehen"sion encourages one to hope that the crea"tive prompting has for-shadowed, and will "continue to satisfy, a need in other minds.
"Excuse me that I wrote but imperfectly, "and perhaps dimly, what I have felt in "reading your article. It has affected me "deeply; and though the prejudice and "ignorant obtuseness which has met my "effort to contribute something towards the "ennobling of Judaism in the conceptions "of the Christian community, and in the "consciousness of the Jewish community, "has never for a moment made me repent "my choice, but rather has been added proof "that the effort was needed—yet I confess "that I had an unsatisfied hunger for cer"tain signs of sympathetic discernment, "which you only have given.
"I may mention, as an instance, your clear perception of the relation between the presentation of the Jewish elements and those of English social life."
Herbert Spencer, who set George Eliot's mind to novel writing, in all probability taught her his doctrine of individualism which extends to nations and peoples, and thus rendered the doctrines of "Romola" and "Deronda" possible conclusions to a most receptive mind.
The writer has had no access to other than printed information and thus must abandon the attempt to identify the "human documents" around whom the book was written. So far as can be ascertained George Eliot had no intimate and but few general Jewish friendships until after the publication of "Deronda." She knew Emanuel Deutsch, the great Talmudic scholar, who died just prior to the publication of the novel George Eliot's interest in the Jews has been traced back to the fifties. Deutsch had undoubtedly imparted to her some of his enthusiasm for Rabbinic literature, for in 1867 she writes enthusiastically: "The Author of the glorious article on the Talmud is 'that bright little man, Mr. Deutsch, a very dear delightful creature.'" He died with some ideal too vaguely sketched to be identifiable, unspoken—was he the real Mordecai Cohen?
Mr. Joseph Jacobs then still, we believe, a Cambridge student, endeavoured to fix the real personalities of the Jewish heroes. Mordecai was one Cohen or Kohn, the hero of a philosophers' club described by Mr. Lewis in his Spinoza article in the "Fortnightly Review" of 1866. Deronda's mother, Leonora Alcharisi, Princess of Hallm Elberstein, had her counterpart in the grandmother of Benjamin d'Israel. Mr. James Picciotto, the author of the "Sketches of Anglo-Jewish History," even hinted at the real "Daniel Deronda"—the late Col. A. E. W. Goldsmid.
George Eliot's journal, as printed, bears no reference to her having been impressed by these personalities and at best they could but have served as moulds into which the author poured ideas which in combination yielded most vivid and impressive beings. Such individuals bear but remote relations to such works; a passing face suggests a thought, its owner is never perhaps conscious of it. The inner fabric of the book suggests that the author was dealing with creatures of the imagination rather than with studied individuals. It may be significant in this respect that "Deronda" is compounded, the word "adorned," "Charisi" from "Ischar."
Daniel, Adorned, probably in view of the purpose of the book a reference to Daniel the prophet of the restoration of Israel, but the vision adorned with modern views and conceptions. Isichar is simply the Biblical Issi-char or Issachar "the strong ass couching between the two burdens who saw the land was pleasant and bowed his shoulder to bear and became a servant to tribute" not a far fetched description of the mother of the hero, in her attitude, her self-satisfaction and her willingness to pay the penalty of de-Judaisa-tion for a comfortable life. These suggestions may seem fanciful, but the character of the book offers them some warrant.
Excepting such guesses at the personalities of the novel as above referred to, identification is probably impracticable for, and here is the distinction between this and other "novels with a purpose," none such existed. Mr. Picciotto admitted this bluntly in his critique in the "Gentleman's Magazine:" "Daniel Deronda" has never braisen and may never live, but Jews have arisen and will again rise who if
