The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 1 · January 1906
6printed page
scan 12 of 54
6
THE MACCABAEAN

length and book by book might be tested for its truths and its achievements. To the same category belongs George Eliot's "Daniel Deronda." but is stands in many respects apart from those mentioned and separate indeed from the whole library of modern fiction.

Few books and no author have been so much discussed as “Daniel Deronda” and George Eliot: the author because of her book: the book because of its author. According to one set of literary critics “Daniel Deronda” is a lifeless effort showing decline of power; others, of whom Mr. Oscar Browning is typical, regard it as the achievement of a woman who amongst English writers is to rank next to Shakespeare. “It is possible that ‘Adam Bede,’ ‘Middlemarch,’ and ‘Daniel Deronda’ may eventually have their place rather beside ‘Hamlet’ and ‘Macbeth’ than beside ‘Tom Jones’ and ‘Clarissa Harlowe.” Few critics, however, have viewed this novel from the right point of view—a novel written with a distinct purpose, a book with a distinct purpose, a book with a ‘message,’ and lacking that insight they have not been able to extend a greater measure of sympathy to the author’s achievement. That George Eliot wrote “Daniel Deronda” for a set purpose is clear enough. She studied Hebrew and the Rabbinic literature, mastered the intricacies of Jewish ceremonial law and obtained a remarkable insight into normal Jewish life. This by itself might be regarded as “cramming” to get correct “local colour.” These facts are, however, supported by correspondence, most serious in its tone, to Mrs. Beecher Stowe, to the late Prof. David Kaufmann of Buda-Pesth University, a great Jewish scholar; by the author’s anxiety as to the reception of its Jewish element and lastly by the little read “Modern Hep. Hep.” the last essay in the volume of “Theophrastus Such” and which in brilliant prose justifies the novel and the position taken up by the author. Nor is this all. George Eliot began her literary career with a distinct prejudice against the Jews. In 1848 she wrote to Miss Mary Sibree, now Mrs. Cash, apropos of d’Israeli’s “Tancred” a phil-lipic against the Chosen People.

"D'Israel is unquestionably an able man "......as to his theory of races, it has not "a leg to stand on, and can only be buoyed

"up by such windy eloquence as—You "chubby-faced, squabby-nosed Europeans "owe your commerce, your arts, your re- "ligion, to the Hebrews,—nay, the Hebrews "lead your armies; in proof of which he "can tell us that Massena, a second-rate "general of Napoleon's, was a Jew, whose "real name was Manasseh. Extermination "up to a cretain point seems to be the law "for the inferior races—for the rest fusion "both for physical and moral ends. It "appears to me that the law by which priv- "ileged classes degenerate from continual "intermarriage, must act on a larger scale "in deteriorating whole races. The nations "have been always kept apart until they "have sufficiently developed their idiosyn- "crasies, and then some great revolutionary "force has been called into action, by which "the genius of a particular nation becomes "a portion of the common mind of hu- "manity. Looking at the matter aesthet- "ically, our idea of beauty is never formed "on the characteristics of a single race. I "confess the types of the pure races, how- "ever handsome, always impress me dis- "agreeably; there is an undefined feeling "that I am looking not at man, but at a "specimen of an order under Cuvier's class "Bimana. The negroes certainly puzzles me. "All the other races seem plainly destined "to extermination, not excepting even the "Hebrew Caucasian. On one point I heartily "agree with d'Israeli as to the superiority "of the Oriental races—their clothes are "beautiful and their manners are agreeable. "Did you not think the picture of the Bar- "roni family interesting? I should like to "know who are the originals. The fellow- "ship of race, to which d'Israeli so exul- "tingly refers the munificence of Sidonia, is "so evidently an inferior impulse, which "must ultimately be superseded, that I won- "der even he, Jew as he is, dares to boast "of it. My Gentile nature kicks most res- "olutely against any assumption of superior- "ity in the Jews, and is almost ready to "echo Voltaire's vituperation. I bow to the "supremacy of Hebrew poetry, but much "of their early mythology, and almost all "their history, is utterly revolting. Their "stock has produced a Moses and a Jesus;