Jewish Self-Defense.
The movement for Jewish Self-Defense, called forth by the recent massacres in Russia, does not waste its energies in protesting against these massacres. In underlining the word "Self" it expresses its conviction of the futility of all kinds of Jewish demonstrations which appeal to others. For the only power, in whose name the Jews are able to protest, is the ideal of humanity, and "ideal" and "humanity" are words which are not understood by the savages in Russia. The Messianic age, when man and beast will live peaceably together, has not yet arrived, and the "black hundred" who performed fiendish atrocities on the Jews, and the so-called liberal "four hundred" who dictated these atrocities from the green table, are equally beasts which have nothing in common with anything that is human. To protest behoves only those who can back their voice of protest with the roar of cannons. But the Jews have no cannons, and the powers, which send warships to Turkey to compel her to introduce European civilization in the province of Macedonia, are deaf and dumb when the same European civilization is stifled in the blood of thousands of Jews. Instead of vainly appealing to others, Jewish Self-Defense makes the Jews stand up for themselves, and instead of passive, humiliating begging, it openly advocates manly and active fighting. The massacres in Kishineff have, for the first time, forced upon the Jews in Russia the conviction of the necessity of Self-Defense. The recent infinitely more horrible massacres in Odessa and other Russian cities have urged the same conviction on many Jews outside of Russia, and have led to the formation of the Jewish Defense Association in America. Alongside with the Relief Fund which is bringing help to those who have already suffered from the Russian atrocities, the Jewish Defense Association, by providing the Jews with proper means for self-defense, endeavors to prevent the occurrence of new atrocities, and thus tries to be—as it were—a relief to the Relief Fund.
There are many thousands of Jews who—openly or secretly—sympathize with the ten-
dencies of the Jewish Defense Association. But there are only very few who fully grasp the significance of the idea which underlies this Association. And yet one may safely say, that the formation of the Jewish Defense Association marks an epoch, constitutes quite a novel and unprecedented feature in the history of the Jews in the exile. The famous aphorism: "If I am not for myself, who will be for myself?" which has become the motto of the Jewish Defense Association, was coined by Hillel nearly two thousand years ago, before that teaching arose whose believers have shed oceans of Jewish blood. And yet, the history of the Jews in the Exile was one continuous crime against this principle. The Jews never were for themselves, but always appealed to the others to do so. They always were, whether in Germany or elsewhere, "Schutzjuden," Jews who had to be protected by others. The spirit of Judas Maccabaeus. who, with a handful of men, arose against the overwhelming forces of the Romans, degenerated into the mediæval "Shtadlan," the representative of the community who cringingly sought the favor of the rulers and mighty ones, generally mingling his voice of wailing with the ringing sound of precious metal. The Jews were heroes in passive endurance, but weaklings in active resistance. When attacked by the mob, they knew no other means of defense than to run to the kings and bishops. The kings and bishops sometimes deemed it profitable to protect the powerless Jews. But more often they did not. Then,—then the Jews shut themselves up in their synagogues and "were treated like sheep led to the slaughter, to be slain, to be destroyed, to be beaten and to be put to shame." So it was in the dark Middle Ages.
The Jewish emancipation which revolutionized everything that is Jewish, has left this attitude of the Jew towards the outside world untouched. The modern Jew who is otherwise ready to boast of his liberalism and independence has remained the same Schutzjude of the Middle Ages. He anxiously watches every nod of a king and