Porte would enjoy an enormous advantage Israelites. Construction of special railroads and establishment of special steamship lines on the Mediterranean under English subsidy. Acquisition of Tyre and building a new city on its site.
"It was his view that not only would the Israelites have a fixed habitation and national existence, but that the Ottoman Porte would enjoy an enormous advantage through the establishment of this new principality in Palestine by reason of the notable increase in population, revenue and military power. Through the new state Turkey would be better guarded against Egypt and would acquire a powerful means of civilization and prosperity for its Asiatic provinces which are the foundations of the strength of the Empire. Similarly the reconstitution of the new Jewish nationality would be of immeasurable advantage to Great Britain; it would give her Oriental governments an impetus never yet seen, enable her to settle all the grave and vital questions which have caused such serious disquietude concerning Syria, Egypt and the Islands of the Southern Sea, and guard all of her interests which might be most seriously menaced in the future."
It seems a pity, certainly from the point of view of the Zionist, that this interesting manuscript has never been published. Political conditions have of course materially changed during the last fifty years. Turkey no longer needs a buffer-state between it and Egypt, nor would the Porte under modern Zionistic schemes be permitted to use the new Jewish State to increase its revenue or its military strength. The argument with reference to Great Britain still holds good, and the advantage to the British Empire of a friendly neutral state at the eastern shores of the Mediterranean is obvious now as in 1851. It is of course impossible to judge how far the plan of Musolino could ever have recommended itself to practical statesmanship. That Lord
Palmerston and the Rothschilds were not impressed by it, and that Musolino was for upwards of thirty years unable to get any practical support for it, may be accounted for by the fact that to them it appeared visionary and impracticable. But times have changed and within the last ten years a similar plan, launched by Dr. Herzl, has been considered most seriously as a political possibility by all the statesmen of modern Europe. Professor Finzi closes his article with these words: "Such was the plan which occupied the summit of the thoughts of Benedetto Musolino before Theodor Herzl was born. Here we have another instance of that happy intuition by which the genius of Italy in science and in 'art, in letters and in philosophy, in civics and in politics, always open to splendors of thought, is destined to foretell the most wonderful discoveries and to anticipate the most lofty aspirations. By comparing the ideals of Musolino and Herzl we are able to deduce another lesson of highest importance. The identity of the ideals of these two men, differing in race, in religion and in language, is not only the result of the thought of two noble kindred spirits but reflects the civil progress and human solidarity which, constantly unfolding, opposes the injustice and prejudices of the past and looks forward to days more serene. The life which is stirring around about the man of genius is always a factor in the direction of his intellect and in the passion of his heart. Let us then salute with joy the plans of Musolino and the deeds of Herzl as signs of the sentiment of fraternity and justice. The one and the other lie in the tomb without having seen the realization of the lofty plan which was the very breath of their noble lives. But their names will be remembered and blessed at all times as well by the descendants of Abraham as by all men of heart."