The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 5 · November 1905
240printed page
scan 20 of 50

even though a small and unimportant one, which had broken its vow with Palestine—and whose purpose, it appeared, was to break with Jewish traditions as well, then the necessity forced itself upon us to clearly express our purpose and not to work ahead on its assumption alone. Before all the world, we therefore declared in unmistakable language that "the Zionist organization stands firmly by the fundamental principle of the Basle program, namely, the establishment of a legally-secured, publicly-recognized home for the Jewish people in Palestine, and it rejects either as an end or as a means all colonizing activity outside Palestine and its adjacent lands."

You all know the troublesome times we passed before this resolution came to a vote. The radical minority used every means to obstruct the vote on the East African offer, and the leaders of the majority insisted that it should not be rejected without the definite declaration of policy as an amendment. The minority desired a free discussion, and the majority consented, but the discussion only added to our weariness—not to our information. When the discussion could not be drawn out any longer, a bitter fight was raised concerning the legality of the election of the Russian delegates. And, finally, when all legitimate means of obstruction had failed, this small minority, with the help of friends who were not delegates, obstructed further business by tumult, disorder and confusion. This was on the memorable Saturday night. The excuses which are now being offered are groundless. The purpose of the minority was too evident. They were determined to prevent action even at the price of causing a collapse of the Congress. It was marvellous with what patience the great body of delegates endured this disorderly and disgraceful conduct. But the danger was imminent. That Saturday night, or rather, early Sunday morning was a critical moment, and many of us, when we reached our hotels that morning did not know whether it was within our power to

convene again; how such persons could be controlled without using violent means no one could say. I need not describe our anxiety! Consider the bare possibility of breaking up the Congress, of the first Congress after Herzl—and you will appreciate our feeling. But the Greater Actions Committe was equal to the emergency. In the forenoon a meeting was held, additional measures to keep order were taken, and the resolution framed which expressed the will of the great majority and embodied the rejection of the East African offer and the clear definition of our purposes. The Congress was reconvened, and barring one unpleasant and well-known incident, it conducted itself quietly, with an almost solemn dignity; the resolutions were adopted unanimously; the obstructive minority now refrained from voting. In thus refraing they acted wisely, for in this manner they hid their weakness.

You may have heard that at the conclusion of the session there was a moment of great happiness; and you may think that it was due to the pleasure in having carried the resolution, for it has been so described. But this was not the case. The "massel tovs" which passed from one to another, many moistened by tears, expressed happiness, because the Congress had passed safely through the great crisis, because the sinister purpose of the obstructionists had been frustrated. And indeed we may well be hanny. For few bodies could have reconvened after such events. Nothing that happened at the Congress inspired one with greater confidence than this, for it proved the inherent strength of our organization! It proved that we have men who do not lose their heads in excitement and whose resources and courage are equal to any crisis.

But we can not for this reason refrain from condemning severely those who thus endangered our movement. We do not feel regret at the withdrawal from the movement of, such who were not with us in principle