The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
174printed page
scan 8 of 54
Facsimile · scan 8 of 54
Scan of p. 174
Text · transcribed from the scan

Christianity? For the Jews, in order to mollify Christianity and exhibit their broadmindedness, have been talking about "Jesus the Jew," and the "world's moral debt to the Jews." Instead of mollifying, it intensified the hurt. And Mr. Warner set about his task with a vim. It was no light task. From Adam to Joshua, from the Judges to the Kings every figure in Scriptural history had to be handled, to be taken off a pedestal and reduced to the proper infinitesimal proportions.

The Savior not a Judean.

And then, the wedge of hypothesis is inserted in the cleavage of Jewish history. The Jews are from the kingdom of Judah and there was in Palestine prior to the dispersion remnants of the kingdom of Israel, together with Idumeans and other strangers. So setting his "literary sub-consciousness" to work, and slighting his New Testament, Mr. Warner suggests that his Redeemer who came from Nazareth, was probably of the tribe of Ephraim, that is, of Israel. And so it is a long story—we Jews can claim no "Yechus" in Christianity. The world, therefore, owes us nothing, we have overrated ourselves, we have been overrated; the purpose for which we were supposed to exist has ceased; we are nothing but a spectre, indeed a "wraith," not even the wreck of former greatness. And to it Mr. Warner authoritatively says, "Begone, disappear, sink into the trapdoor of the past and come not out of the hole as anything distinguishable from other men."

Facts not in accord with his Theory.

Of course Mr. Warner builds up other hypothesis to support other theories correlated to the main issue, for he finds in Judaism as it is to-day certain facts which are provokingly at variance with what it

should be according to his deductions, but they are of the same order—interesting examples of how a literary consciousness can be of use in the narrow corner of argument.

Mr. Warner the Minimiser

Still it is well to understand him. He is the minimiser. He tells the world not to fear but to discount the Jew by a huge percentage. They have done nothing and great names attest not to the variety of their achievement. And when he does fall across a great name that runs too heavily counter to his theory, he neatly dismisses it by suggesting that this man was only accidently a Jew ext_text_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for_json_for Still it is well to understand him. He is the minimiser. He tells the world not to fear but to discount the Jew by a huge percentage. They have done nothing and great names attest not to the variety of their achievement. And when he does fall across a great name that runs too heavily counter to his theory, he neatly dismisses it by suggesting that this man was only accidently a Jew—his strength or his greatness was European in its origin and in its manifestation. Of course this kind of argument leaves the spectre very impalpable even as a ghost.

We never had a great man, and if we did he was not a Jew at all. To translate a Yiddishism, "Do him something!" But we have no intention. The literature of apologetics began with Josephus, it should never have been extended. At any rate we do not intend to add to it.

No Apologetics.

THE fact is, Mr. Warner's book is provocative of defense, if not apology, but obviously a defense to a voluminous book, filled with all sorts of inaccuracies, would be a foolhardy attempt. There would be no end to defense if every pamphleteer were given the attention he seems to demand by his audacious attack. Mr. Warner's attack is all the more reprehensible because it seems to be directed against clericalism, rather than against the Jews. For our crime is not our own self-valuation but its use as authority by those who maintain the clerical institution. He smites for ourselves, but more so for what others do--with our name.