The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
200printed page
scan 34 of 54

אבל כבר הכו אותו על קדקרו שהרי מצינו הרבה מעשיות בגמ' וכו' וע' זוהר שם וכן קמיעין בהרבה מקומות ולחשים רבו מלספר. והפלוסופיא הטתו ברוב לקחה לפרש הגמרא הכל בדרך הלציי ולעקור אותם מפשטן וח"ו אינו מאמין בהם ולא מהמונם אלא כל הדברים הם כפשטן אלא שיש בהם פנימיות, לא פנימיות של בעלי הפלוסופיא שהם חצוניות אלא של בעלי האמת.

That this passage is an interpolation can admit of no dispute. Not only did his disciples consider it a gloss (51), but its verbosity and the frequent repetitions it contains prove that it could not have come from the hand of the Gaon, whose style is so terse as often to make his meaning obscure (52). Besides, its spirit is out of harmony with that of the Gaon's entire system. Not only his disciples, but even his opponents said of him that he favored philosophy (53).

מי יתן ואמצאהו ואערכה לפניו משפטנו להסיר מעלינו את כל תלונותיו ומענותיו, הפלוסופיא אשר הלך בעקבותיהם לפי דברי תלמידיו לחקור אלהות בשכל אנושי.

His works, as enumerated in the Jewish Encyclopedia (Vol. V, article Elijah ben Solomon), are the following:

Biblical.

Aderet Eliyahu, a commentary on the Pentateuch, in which he endeavored to give the exact meaning of the verses, showing that there is not a single letter too much, Dubrovna, 1804.

Commentary to the Prophets and Hagiographa. The only parts published were Proverbs (Sklov, 1798); the portion of Joshua containing the description of Palestine and that of Ezekiel containing the description of the Temple, under the title

(51). See Kiryah Neemanah, p. 152.(52). Cf., Ben Abraham, Achiasaf, 1898-1899.(53). Shne'ur Solomon, Introduction to Mezaref Hoavodah, Koenigsberg, 1858.

of "Zurat ha-Arez" (ib. 1802); Jonah (Wilna, 1800); Isaiahi-xiii; Habakkuk and Chronicles (ib. 1820); the Song of Songs (Warsaw, 1842); and Job i-viii. (ib. 1854).

Talmudic.

Shenot Eliyahu, long and short commentaries on Zera’im, revised by his pupil Haylim of Volozhin. Lemberg, 1799.

Eliyahu Rabbah, on Tohorot, compiled by his pupil Meir of Wilna. Bruenn, 1802.

Commentary on Kedoshim and a mystical commentary on the Biblical passages quoted in the Mishnah, both extant in manuscript.

Efat Zedek, glosses to the Mekilta. Wilna, 1844.

Commentary and glosses to the Sifra. Glosses to the Sifre.

Tohorot ha-Kodesh (also called "Zer Zohab"), commentary on Tosef., Tohorot. Zolkiev, 1804.

Glosses to Tosof., Zera'im, Mo'ed, and Nashim. Wilna, 1837.

Yerushalmi.

Commentary on the order Zera’im. Mishnah Eliyahu, glosses to the treatise Shekinah, printed in the “Taklin Hadtin” of his pupil, Israel of Sklov, Minsk, 1812.

Eaeli.

Hagahot ha-Gera (ha-Gaon Rabbenu Eliyahu), being a selection from glosses to the whole Talmud written by Elijah; published in the edition of the Talmud. Vienna, 1806.

Glosses to Abot de-Rabbi Natan and to the small treatises; printed with his commentary to Abot. Sklov, 1804.

Novellae on eight treatises of the Talmud.

Halakic.

Commentary on the four parts of the Sklov, 1803; Yoreh De'ah, Grodno, 1806; Eben ha-'Ezer, Wilna, 1819; Hoshen Mishpat, Koenigsberg.

Collectanea on Maimonides. Novellae on Asheri.

Haggadic.

Glosses to Pirke Rabbi Eli’eser. Warsaw, 1832.