The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
195printed page
scan 29 of 54

עובר עבירה חלילה, אוי ג"כ השכינה מתלבשת בו, כי בלתה ובלעדה לא היה נוי כח להניע שום אבר ואפילו ביחוד של נאוף ושקר, הוא יתברך מחיה אותו שעה ונותן בו כה.

Though some of our modern writers in their desire for that which is novel endeavor to find a good side in Chassidism and to present it in a favorable light, no one will deny that the sect aimed at abolishing, or at least diminishing study of every kind, that it created an idolatrous worship of the "Zaddik," and that it practised a cult which was un-Jewish. That the Chassidim "were second to no other sect in their loyalty and affection for one another," is but natural. A small group of people who are persecuted in the same cause must necessarily be drawn into a closer union with each other.

As long as the sect confined itself to the remote and insignificant villages of the Ukraine, and the other dark parts of Russia, its un-Jewish cult could be practiced with impunity. Later, however, when in consequence of the Cossack persecution, many emigrated and came as far as Lithuania, the Talmudists rose in indignation against the new sect. Wilna, as the most important Jewish center of Lithuania, was the first to declare war upon it. It was evident, however, that unless the Gaon who was at that time admired and revered by every Jewish scholar in Europe, sanctioned the proceedings against the Chassidim, their mischievous practices could not be checked. Hence when the rabbis met in Wilna, in 1777, and agreed to pronounce the "cherem" against the Chassidim, the Gaon was asked to give his approval to it. Contrary to his usual practice of abstaining from any participation in controversies, he signed the document of excommunication, attaching thereto the following comment (37):

ואַף שַׁאִין מִדְרָכִי לְצַאַת חוּץ מִגְדַּרִיעַכ"ו לְעַת הַפְּרוֹ תוּרְתוֹ עַת לְעִשׁוּת וּבּוֹ

לְכִן גם אָנַכִי אָבוּאַ עַל הַחֲתָוֹם יוֹם כ"דמַנְחָם תַּקְּמ"א לְפַ"ק, נָאִם אַלְיָהוּבְּמוּהָרִש"ו זְצַלְלָה"ה.

After the "ban" had been signed by Elijah, a mass-meeting was held in the Grand Synagogue, a thousand lights were lighted, the shofar blown, and the excommunication read from the pulpit. After the "cherem" had been read in Wilna and also at the fair in Zelva, where merchants gathered yearly from all parts of Russia, Solomon of Ladi, perhaps the most important of the Chassidim, wished to have an interview with the Gaon, but was not admitted by the latter, who feared that such an interview was calculated to lead the people to believe that he had turned in favor of Chassidism—a belief which actually became current a little later through the trickery of the Chassidim.

The Gaons’s peace-loving disposition did not allow him to persevere in the persecution of the Chassidim. After signing the excommunication he desisted from further participating in the controversy. Meanwhile the Chassidim, resorting to a trick, gave rise to the impression that the Gaon had ben won over to their cause. A blind man was sent by them to various cities, accompanied by a boy who introduced him as the son of Elijah of Wilna. In reply to inquiries about his father’s attitude towards Chassidism he would state that Elijah had recanted, and that advanced age alone prevented him from doing penance and traveling in person to preach the Chassidic doctrines. At first this trick was effective, for many, taking the silence of the Gaon for consent, joined the new sec. But when this came to the.ears of the Gaon had been won over to their cause. ered at Hamburg by a Lithuanian merchant—he sent, in 1796, two of his disciples, Chayim, of Serhey, and Sa’adiah, to all the principal communities of Russia, to denounce the detestable sect in a new de-