The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
192printed page
scan 26 of 54
192
THE MACCABAEAN

we come to treat of his works (22). Not only did he make a thorough study of philosophy, but he often quotes the "More" approvingly (23). Once the complaint was made to him that the "dayan" of Wilna, Judah Ashkenazi, recited the "More" daily before his disciples, and he was urged to prohibit this practice. But he exclaimed in indignation (24):

הרבינו משה יורה ואני אפיר? מי יתןהלקי עמו.

And it is but natural that Elijah should have favored philosophy, for, as Schechter points out, he represented truth both in his literary activity, and in his life, which was one unceasing longing and effort after truth. Not only was he content, on the physical side, with a mere sustenance of life in this world, but he lived uprightly apart from any consideration of the hereafter. When asked for his views on the doctrine of reward in the next world he would say (25):

אליהו יכול לעבוד לאלהים גם בלי עולםהבא.

Only that, he would frequently say to his disciples, was of any value, which has been acquired by one's own hard labor. If an angel, he said, were sent to teach him the mysteries of the Law, he would not accept his services. We are told in the name of his disciple, R. Chaim, of Volozhin (26), that on a certain occasion the Gaon did not eat for three days because he was occupied in trying to unravel the mysteries of a very difficult passage, and it was only after he had found some clue to the meaning that he partook of food.

So advanced and liberal was he in his

(22). Chapter VII. (23). Cf., Jawitz, Kenesseth Yisroel, 1886. Also Introduction to Peath Hashulchan, Saffed, 1836.

(24). Fuenn, Kiryah, Ne'emanah, pp. 152 and 280.

(25). Brainin, Mimizrach Umima'arob, vol. IV., 1899.

(26). Aliath Eliohu, p. 33.

views, that, almost three quarters of a century before the practice of uncovering the head was introduced into the synagogue in Germany, he held that bareheadedness was no sin, even during prayer, but that custom did not sanction it. In view of the fact that his contemporaries regarded bareheadedness during prayer as almost equivalent to the violation of one of the Ten Commandments, only as great a man as the Gaon could permit himself to be so outspoken in his views. His saint-like life, his great fame, and his universally acknowledged piety, saved him from the charge of heresy.

But the Gaon disregarded not only the prejudices of his own time, but those of all times. He could not tolerate dishonesty and falsehood, no matter where found. Thus, for instance, in commenting on the decision of the Yore Deah that the superstitious custom of slaughtering any hen that crows like a cock may be kept up, but that this must not be the reason given for the slaughtering, he exclaims: (27):

דבריו קשים כחומץ לשניים וכעשן לענייםלגנוב דעת המקום.

No wonder, then, that the people of Wilna revered such a man as a saint, and considered it a happy event in one's life to have conversed with him, or to have been of any service to him. No wonder that all the scholars of his time recognized him as their master. It seems as if nature had bestowed all her gifts upon that one man. Besides possessing the other qualities referred to above, he was endowed with a remarkable memory which can scarcely find its equal. After having read a book once, he was able to recite its contents from memory the rest of his life. His keen insight and quick and sure grasp were still more marvelous. The most complicated passages in Talmudis literature, over which other scholars had to pore for days

(27). Cf., the commentary on Yore Deah, 179:8.