The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 4 · October 1905
189printed page
scan 23 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
189

The study itself was a meritorius, Godpleasing deed. It mattered little whether it led to practical results; the one who busied himself with the study of the Talmud was a righteous man and entitled to the support of the community. All of its teachings were beyond doubt true; the conclusions of its debates were fixed verities. To suggest that the knowledge of the Tanaim and Amoraim was deficient in certain respects was a grievous sin. If inconsistencies, errors, and incongruities were found in the Talmud, they were to be explained away by dialectical methods, wherever this was possible; and where it was not, the teachings of the Talmud were still accepted as true, in the firm conviction that any lack of clearness was due entirely to the ignorance of the student. The Talmudist, therefore, not wishing to confess himself ignorant, would search deeply into every statement before putting it aside as inexplicable (7). Thus pilpulism developed, and dialecticism became so prevalent that every difficulty in the Talmud could in some way be bridged over. I. B. Levinson relates that the desciples of Jacob Pollack once tore out several pages of the tractate he was reading to them, and that to their great surprise their teacher read on without observing that any pages were missing, all the while combining, in a most subtle way, subjects which were not in any way connected. Nor was this objectionable, superficial method restricted to the study of the Talmud alone. Every subject was studied not for the sake of knowledge, but in order to bring out some "pshetel." The reader did not care to know what A. or B. said upon any specific topic, but he strove to discover some real or apparent contradiction in their statements, which he could then proceed to reconcile. For to the authors of this period, as Prof. Schechter says, the preceding Jewish literature did not mean a fountain of living waters, sup-

(7). Cf., H. Gersoni, in The Independent, Sept. 19, 1895.

plying men with truth and religious inspiration, but rather a kind of armory providing them with juristic cases over which to fight, and to outdo each other in sophistry and subtlety.

Elijah was the first to check this mischief. He introduced the most searching critical methods in the study of the Talmud, and thus elevated it to a science. His corrections and emendations were neither mere guesswork nor artificial structures, but such as were justified and often even necessitated by a comparison of texts and original sources. He required his disciples to study the Talmud in such a way as to be able to analyse each tractate, to know in each discussion who were the Tanaim and Amoraim mentioned therein, and what each of these rabbis stood for.

Common sense was with him the conditio sine qua non in all studies (8). He was the first to recognize— Geiger pointed it out after him—that just as there are two modes of explaining the Bible, derash and peshat, so are there two corresponding methods in the explanation of the Mishnah. In order, therefore, to understand the Mishnah properly, we must not accept the comments of the Amoraim upon it, but we must interpret it literally and independently of the Gemara (9). But Elijah would not have any one study the Talmud unless he had first carefully studied the Bible. With him, in fact, the careful and grammatical study of the Bible always took the first place among the studies. The other scholars of that time neglected the Bible altogether (10). They religiously studied the Talmud, Code, and the Commentaries, but all they knew of the Bible they obtained indirectly through the Talmud. So generally was this the case, that it has been shown that out of a hundred

(8). Cf., the Gaon's Commentary to Proverbs, xi:5.

(9). Bernfeld, "Toldoth Hareformation Hadosith" (p. 115), Cracow, 1900.

(10). Cf., Yore Deah, 245:76.