The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 3 · September 1905
126printed page
scan 8 of 54

transparently clear—the son does not share the opinion which his father held. That there are some fathers, some thousands of fathers, who stand by the oldest views, is no doubt true, but we rather have in mind those who have at least a glimmering of modern knowledge. That some sons, who are fairly well aware of what is thought and known in the modern world, stand firm by the teachings of their elders, yielding not a jot or a tittle of the law, by no means alters the position of the mass, who can admire but cannot imitate them. Orthodoxy claims the sympathy of the younger generation because the issue is not one of form but of substance.

The younger generation knows nothing and cares less for theology. The Christian world has been affected by the same phenomena, and theological works are more than ever a drug on the market. Jewish writers practically avoid the issue, and we do not recall a single serious story which attempts to deal with the religious Jewish problem. It is providing the historic background without daring to raise a heart cry, Back to Hebraic Tradition.

MODERN VIEWS.

A generation that eschews theology, that favors a rationalist's sentimentalism cannot be moved by the ideas which make the New Year and the Day of Atonement, Days of Awe to the older generation. The New Year t osuch is not preparatory to the Day of Judgment, and Yom Kippur appears to them in no such sinister light. The positive weakening of interests in the Hoshanna Rabba is proof that this idea of the Judgment Day, magnificently expressed by Rabbi Meir, has lost its hold on our age.

Nor is this entirely new. For more than twenty years the Jews in England have been trying to read into Atonement the words Atonement, and discovering in community of spirit the value, beauty and reason for the general observance of the Kippur. And whereas in any large congre-

gation of Russian-born Jews one still witnesses copious tears, invocative expressions, and passionate pleadings on the days mentioned, the equally seriously orthodox Jews of Holland or Frankfurt would be much amazed at such scenes and sounds. Certain phrases of thought are therefore not matters of acclimatisation. It is the want of preception in regard to such obvious facts that keep the two wings of orthodoxy apart, and compels reform ineffectually to beat its wings on idle air.

FAITH AND PEOPLE.

The times are certainly more tolerant, the disaffection of the younger generation was so great that its return will be and is accepted on almost any conditions, but in going back the younger generation is itself far from clear as to what it thinks. As we see it young men and women are receptive, willing to be influenced, but indeterminate as to what they seek in matters spiritual and religious.

Yet Judaism, the religion, through its avowed exponents, must sooner or later seek to come to an understanding with its own followers. The advances as far as they go have been made by the oldest school of orthodoxy, rather than by the more modern, or more experienced element. It is from conservative Russia that has come the inspiration to found the Mizrachi, a movement that at root is actuated by the thought that the older generation must seek to live with the younger, and which no doubt will eventually seek to remingle religious ideals with national aspirations.

THE RETURN.

An accounting of the Jewish world would find us all more inclined towards religion than we were a decade back, it would find us more willing to yield to the natural revivalism of the High Festivals than we were then; but it is for men of power of thought and persuasion to lead us back, or rather forward to the joy and strength of faith. The Shofar as it is blown this New