To THE MACCABAEAN:
As I have read Dr. Nordau's presidential address, I was most astonished to read his views in regard to the policy of the Jew in Palestine. On page 87, he speaks the truth of the great political changes which are making history in Russia. "The Jew would be false to his principle," he pleads, "if he would not side with freedom and progress, democracy and enlightenment, against autocracy and the power of darkness." But what does he mean when, on page 88, he wants us to affiliate with the darkness of all ages, the Sultan of Turkey, and he wants us to stand between the battle of freedom and the maintenance of darkness? No, the Jew cannot gain freedom at the expense of other people's welfare. The Jew should rather suffer as before, and not accept anything unless it comes with righteousness.
Is he willing to place the Jew between the Devil and the Black Sea? Who blames the Arabians for revolting against that Turkish government? Russia with all her darkness, shines in comparison with the government called the Sultan, a government that permits caravans to rob as long as it gets a share of the plunder. Governors of one nationality are appointed to govern another nationality and rob them and tax them as long as he pays a certain fixed amount to the national government. Five hundred thousand Armenians killed in one year! There is not a place on the globe where there is more murder and disorder than in the Turkish domain, and yet the great Nordau, with his great mind, advises us to get in between the enemies' guns. The Sultan begs you to keep away from him. He has even forbidden you
to own a piece of land. He does not want to shed the Jewish blood!
But if the Jews will be foolish enough to push themselves between two fires, there certainly will be a great conflagration. The Jew should better wait patiently. There certainly will be changes on the map and perhaps there will be a chance for Israel. The small colonisation idea is very foolish. If we cannot get Palestine with a clear title of self-government, with real independence, then there is no use of talking about it. I certainly feel that you will not print this article, but it makes no difference, and I remain,
Yours very truly,
J. GOODMAN.
To The Maccabaean:
A public meeting was held on May 14, in the Beth Jacob Synagogue. I beg to report that Rabbi Levy was the speaker of the evening. Thirty-six new members were enrolled. There were present in the little Synagogue 275 to 300 people. The meeting was presided over by myself.
I have so far received only two copies of THE MACCABAEAN. I must say that the publication is one of the best, if not the best, of any Jewish publication and I hope that the publication will have abundant success. Enclosed please find draft for $3.00 for one year's subscription to THE MACCABAEAN, for the Carmel Zion Society of Oakland. The Cantor Levy of Oakland sang several songs, with the Hatikwah ,and the meeting adjourned. Miss Fisher, vice-president of the Daughters of Zion gave a recitation, and I have hard work in building up the Society as we have the Rev. Dr. and his followers working hard against us, but I don't lose courage.