The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 3 · September 1905
161printed page
scan 43 of 54
Facsimile · scan 43 of 54
Scan of p. 161
Text · transcribed from the scan

the movement suffers by his withdrawal. Nevertheless there is balm in every pain. We now see Mr. Zangwill clearly, perhaps even more clearly than he sees himself. He is for the Jews but not with them. He feels with the Jewish people, he espouses the Jewish cause, but in the last resort he does not feel with the Jewish people as one of them, and therefore resists the stream that forces him into the Jewish ranks. This is not the first time we have made this suggestion as to the source of strange inconsistencies in the Zangwillian word and deed. We repeat it now, because the Zionists have nothing to fear from the "Jewish Territorial Organisation." We regret it. There was just a possibility that the new party might create sufficient stir to put Zionists on their mettle. We had even a hope that those who were moved to consider the Zangwillian manifesto might be led into the Zionist camp. All that seems impossible. A few eclectics may support this new organisation, but the bulk of the people will refuse to be stirred by this Zionism without Zion.

We do not minimise the economic and social needs of the Jewish people when we say that they will not follow a mere social and economic theory. No state has been built that has not the passion of life behind it. Herzl understood this when he refused to follow the “Freeland” idea; he understood it still more when he found that only those whorhad faith in Jewish nationalism would support his Jewish State scheme. Mr. Zangwill, who has so often twitted others with not learning the lesson of history, has this time neglected the teaching even of the nast ten years. The Nationalists are bound close to Palestine and the non-Nationalists advocate philanthropy, not state building. It is before this fact that Mr. Zangwill must eventually bow.

Had Mr. Zangwill accepted the voting of the majority at Basle, he would have done a wise thing; he would have set a useful example to other freelances. The

Jews need such. We approach a state in practice in proportion to our obedience and acceptance of the theoretical state law. Success might justify Mr. Zangwill, even as revolution has always justified rebellion; but there is no hope for such achievement.

For the present we must part company with Mr. Zangwill, and the Territorialists to whom Palestine is a minor issue. They will come back to us the better Zionists for realising that Zionism expresses the feelings of our people.

Representation.

THE tragi-comedy of the Witte deputation has almost played itself out, and a poor play it has proved to be. From as many viewpoints as there are in Jewry, come shouts of disapproval at it. Some claim that it was not sufficiently representative because it did not include a minister; others object to the President of the B'nai B'rith engaging upon a task which the B'nai Order had not approved. Members of the Order think the method of the deputation has deprived the B'nai B'rith of some of the glory that should have come to it. New York's East Side desired to be "inat the death," but was wholly snubbed. European publicists object to Jewish financiers approaching M. Witte; the deputation itself has had to insist that it talked no finance with the Russian Envoy; and there is a neat little knot in the history of the deputation as to whether it met M. Witte at his invitation or whether the B'nai B'rith request did not lead to the request for Jewish company. Out of it all there has come one fact which in words of our old song, "had nothin' to do with the case," we now know the name of the lady whom M. Witte married.

The chit-chat criticism is, after all, of little importance, but there is a big issue at stake in this matter. There can be no doubt that the five men who called on M. Witte, are each in their way, representative Jews, but they are not Jewish representa-