An Instance.
Of course our indeterminate character has its pet explanation, or shall we say ‘cause—the paradoxical position of the Jew renders of him necessity so pliant of thought that by the time he has assimilated 'everyone’s ideas, he is lacking one of his own. The picture that we draw is in marked contrast to that which outside writers would paint. In fact so many have read over and over again of the sturdy, world- defying Jew ‚of an indomitable resistance, that they no doubt believe that they themselves with their haphazard ideas really belong to such a people. Parenthetically we may add, that we even anticipate a certain scolding for describing the Jew as we see him, rather as he is supposed to be. ‚But that is not to the point.
Our reflection is drawn from us by a host of recent happenings, in themselves in no way related but all in the end bringing us to one result, that flabbiness is the only characteristic of the normal Jewish mind. There was, for instänce, a Conference of Reform Rabbis which, in order to over- ‘throw some mysteriöus anti-Sabbatarian element, resolved the traditional Sabbath into being. This almost looks like something ‘definite. But it is not; for these rabbis 'avoided üundertaking to set the example in 'Seventh Day Sabbath observance, and in- 'stead addressed the layman—who does not exist in Israel—without suggesting, how- "ever, how prevailing economic conditions an be overcome. Now, we are thoroughly in line with the advocacy of a seriously observed Jewish Sabbath, and this is no virtue in us, any more than it is in any rabbi, or in any other Jew, and the bulk of us believe, somehow, in the observance of the Sabbath; but the hard thought which should occupy the minds of our religious guides, of every shade of belief, is, how is it to be carried out. We do not intend to pursue the matter further, for it wauld carry us beyond our main argument.
Rabbinic Irresponsibility.
At this same conference Rabbi Krauskopf, its president, denying the religious basis amongst the Jews, finding it necessary to build where he had destroyed, calmly propounded the idea that the Jews are united by a social tie. Even his fellow rabbis felt it necessary to rebuke him, and they have been claiming the hospitality of the press in order to dispel the bad impression made by Rabbi Krauskopf's utterance. As a matter of fact, as far as we could observe, the languid community received the rabbi's languid thought with absolute nonchalance. This laconicism is very bad for the mental health of the people.
If one comes close to such issues with the men concerned in them, say one points this out to a rabbi, he, with charming debonair replies, "Oh, but you must not take Rabbi Krauskopf seriously." The insouciance of the observation renders an irritating reply impossible, so that we are in our turn reduced to a limpid condition, unable to decide whether the Philadelphian rabbi merits the cold steel of serious argument. And if we pause for a moment to dwell on the point, it is merely to point out that that way lies danger, catastrophe for the rabbinate. There must be steel in the acts, and iron in the thought of the rabbi, else the next generation, out of sheer languor, will forget to resolve the rabbi into office.
The B’nai B’rith.
Now, again, there is a remarkable message issued by the new president of the Independent Order of B'nai B'rith. Mr. Kraus undertakes not to do what he was not asked to do, to wit, he will not lend himself to agitation on the Russian situation, and he pleads a general avoidance of effort because agitation may jeopardise the work of Mr. Roosevelt in arranging the success of the Peace Conference. What Mr. Kraus was asked to consider was the convening of a national conference of all the