The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
7scan
of 62
Facsimile · scan 7 of 62
Scan of scan 7
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

Notes and Reflections

"Flabby."

The modern Jewish world is somewhat unequally divided between two elements, one of which is continually moved by its own unrest, the other is not only stagnant in its life, but it piteously avoids approaching all things except those of personal and commercial importance. It must not be assumed that these two classes are of a permanent character. The man who has educated himself up to advanced radicalism in matters religious is often the most fearfully nervous in the consideration of all Jewish matters which are not of a religious character. On the other side there sometimes appears the Jew who cannot understand that serious study does not enable one to take anything, even religion, for granted, but who, whilst he trembles at every religious criticism, is equal to the most advanced thought in other directions. Of course there are two such classes in every people, though we are inclined to believe that in other peoples the grain runs through and through, and a man's whole make-up is either conservative or radical.

Why is it that the elements are so indeterminate amongst us? There is a word that might characterise a good percentage of the members of any Jewish community, a commonplace and unpleasant word—flabby. Mr. Lipsky has, in his rendition of Spector's stories (The Judean Press), translated this term into "Mr. Neither-Here-nor-There," an idiomatic Yiddishism too long for our ready use.

"Hush."

There is a way of saying nothing, which is very brilliant, for instance, Thier’s answer, “he could be silent in seven languages,” where the effort is to conceal thought, but behind it is the possibility of saying something, if one choose. But there fs a vast saying of nothing in our midst, which ends where it began, in a mass of indefinite verbiage. There is another attitude, the tragi-comedy of modern existence, in which the good people stand with finger on lips, and deep mystery in their eyes, and you even meet with the gurgled whisper, “things are happening.” And nothing happens! Since these councillors of silence do not even know what they would like to happen—nothing of serious import happens.

Whatever the Jews may be individually, the Jews in the mass are the most unsuccessful people in the world because of this diffuseness of ideas. And nowhere is this lack of success so marked as in the United States. For elsewhere, though the Jews are often equally uncertain as to their own ideas, they have built themselves certain institutions, whose set and form carry them beyond themselves and their intentions, whose existence calls, from time to time, for certain action, some good, some bad, but tend by the compulsory considerations of issues to promote definite results, as definite as a compromising, hesitating body of debators can arrive at.