The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
118printed page
scan 56 of 62

lacks what in England is known as the "cross-bench mind," and ranged himself on the side of those who, whilst still calling themselves Zionists, began to urge that Zionism must be divorced from Palestine, and thus forced every political Zionist to make common cause with those who hold the most narrow views on the methods of the Zionist movement.

East Africa is therefore dead as far as the Zionist movement is concerned. The appeal for East Africa was based on an immediate sentiment. The Basle program is the expression of a permanent sentiment, and an overwhelming logic. The Basle program won. And where do we stand to-day? On the highest pedestal that we have stood on in two thousand years of our history. The attitude of the majority was well described by one speaker: We have arrived at a turning point in our history, we will no longer accept anything that is offered us, we will no longer accept everything that is offered us, we will no longer go wherever we are told to go, we know what we want and we will hew the path of our own choosing. We fully realise how thousands of Jews will consider this refusing the bird in the hand for the two in the bush, but behind this vast impracticability of ours is that national strength which carries nations to their destiny, and ours is certainly not written in the plateau of the East African Protectorate.

A nation that can resist its needs for its greater good has within it that element which makes for a sturdy future, and therefore out of the trouble of the Seventh Congress we see arise a movement, still the Zionist movement, but greater than that which was heretofore, and which will conquer.

Men and Measures.

THE Congress developed some of the better known men, but we cannot see that from the reports to hand that it made any new reputations. The sought-for leader was not there. Dr. Nordau did the best

that could be done under trying circumstances, but the fact that he had to refuse a part in the leadership no doubt weakened his position, independent of the health considerations which compelled him to refuse the proffered office. Ussischkin comes out with flying honors, but with nothing of permanent strength. Prof. Warburg becomes the leader of the Palestinean work, and no doubt the best acknowledgments fell to the lot of Mr. Greenberg who came triumphantly out of a most trying situation. Dr. Gaster apparently preferred to play his part in the semi-obscurity of the committee room. It is therefore but natural that the Congress should have fallen back upon an executive of seven men whose work has been tried almost from the beginning, and who have never been wanting in loyalty to the cause.

We do not know that the shifting of the centre of organization to the German capital, or to Cologne, with the members of the executive resident in different cities, will work out successfully, but this will be remedied if it fails, and provision has been made for this possible defect. More important still will be the work which the Greater Actions Committee has decided upon.

Petty colonisation, and work in Palestine which contravene the principles of the Basle program will not be undertaken. It will therefore be of interest to see what plans Prof. Warburg will formulate to advance the Jewish position in Palestine. He seems to be of opinion that active work can be undertaken there, and by that we understand something more than olive tree planting. The sentiment of the Congress seemed to favor an economic interest in Palestine which will create a practical Jewish influence in the country. This not only sounds sane, but Herzl, too, had it in mind, and the Jewish Colonial Trust branches in Jaffa and Jerusalem were in his view the preliminary steps to economic activity on the part of the Jews. But the opportunity was