The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
117printed page
scan 55 of 62
Facsimile · scan 55 of 62
Scan of p. 117
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

Editorial Pages. J. de Haas, Editor.

The Congress.

Dr. NorpAau, who has a marked ability for coining phrases that stick, this time permitted the wish to be the father of the thought. The Seventh Congress was far from being the Sabbatical Congress. Reversing the legend of the River Sambayton it was the seventh day, of Congresses, that was unruly and turbulent. Out of the hurIy-burly of reports we gather the first significant fact known to all of us for a vear—Herzl was not there, neither his gavel nor his brain; and yet that movement which was to join him in his eternal rest, comes from the mourning full of the fire of life, full of a new strenuousness, albeit it is the fire, and the strenuousness of unquiet, unrest, and some bitterness. Let us put it down as it appears at a distance with its scenes of disorder, its rupture, and the creation of a new Jewish party, the Territorialists, and we are face to face with something full of the zeal of men who love and men who fight, men who have opnions, men shrewd in the ways of strategy, and men who have still to learn our western conception of parliamentarianism. We defend nothing in those scenes which almost amounted to a riot—they are among the faults with which the Golus visit us the sins that come upon us in the third generation because our fathers did not along ago take to open discussion.

Nor are we afraid to approach again these men who knew not how to control themselves in a trying hour. The Jews are not Spartans nor Stoics, and the examples they have seen before them in Eastern Europe, and even in the west of the Continent, have not taught them the best

in the public conduct of affairs. We regret only that these storms of passion should have beclouded the Congress, and occupied so much of its time that its powers of positive legislation were limited. We who would build a state must learn from these experiences these two lessons: (1) that the number of delegates must be diminished, by increasing the basis of representation, for the Congress is too large for practical politics; (2) and that the Congress must extend its sessions so that they last one or even two whole weeks. For we trace most of the disturbance to the crowding of the delegates and the hastiness of the deliberations, the fear that everything that might be said has not, or will not, be said.

East Africa.

WE bade farewell in our last issue to the East African project under the impression that even Mr. Zangwill had dropped that issue. But Mr. Zangwill refused to allow his hobby to die a natural and quiet death. He forced the issue to the front, and became the spokesman of the Territorialists, who, without him, we are inclined to think, would have subsided to about where the Fraction was left in the Sixth Congress. It was beyond question that, with the report of the Commission before it, the Congress could not accept the British offer, and therefore the issue turned upon the terms of its rejection. Mr. Zangwill had a brilliant intellectual but unconvincing position. We cannot accept this, he said, but let us appeal to the British Government for a more extended offer. If this had not run concurrent with a movement to overthrow the avowed principle of the Basle program, this suggestion might diplomatically have served the purposes of the movement. Mr. Joseph Cowen came nearer to the real possible position than anyone else. The Congress might have done what Herzl most desired, it might have made the East African offer the stepping stone to Zion. But Mr. Zangwill