The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
113printed page
scan 51 of 62

Out of the gentle talker, the feeling narrator, out of the spiritually dramatic poet there came a brave and constant statesman with wide purview, with an exalted goal in almost impassable paths.

Fault-finders have put it round that Herzl did not create Zionism; he found it all ready, and had appropriated the work of his predecessors without giving them credit for it. But I lay down firmly from personal knowledge that unfortunately he knew of no predecessors. He discovered Zionism in his heart. He constructed it systematically in his spirit. Only years after he was quite ready did he become acquainted with Pinsker and Moses Hess. These were the meetings that gladdened him, but they came too late to teach him anything,

It is sometimes jokingly asked, what would have become of Liszt and Paganini if they had come into this world with their specific genius before the discovery of the piano or the violin. Herzl's appearance offers the reply. He was the veritable Liszt or Paganini who was born before the discovery of the instrument in which alone he could demonstrate his genius.

Herzl was a born statesman of the first rank, without a state, without a people, without any proper means by which a man may conduct practical politics. His case exists not alone. The Jewish race is ever producing from time to time statesmanly talent for which there is no call. Many create a field of action for themselves; but it is outside of their own people. For example, Disraeli, for whom the Jewish community was indeed too circumscribed, since even the British empire was hardly wide enough for him. Herzl, I say it calmly, careful not to let myself be carried to exaggeration, Herzl had the material for another Disraeli. He could have become one if he had done what Lord Beaconsfield did. But he would not do it. He consigned himself to the martyrdom of conducting "la haute politique" with an

empty hand—a great policy for the Jewish people whose official representatives and teachers denied that it was a people.

teachers denied that it was a people. Herzl advanced coolly to forge a people out of human dust, without common will or aim, to win a land for this people without an army or a fleet, without finances, from governments which only reckon with these factors to get concessions. This was an undertaking that might have frightened back the bravest. It was an undertaking with no future, said the antagonists of Zonism. But Herzl was convinced of its feasibleness, and did not let himself be thwarted when others called that a Utopia which he looked on as a necessary and possible work.

It was a great mistake to say that Herzl had no judgment. He had, on the contrary, a sharp critical sense and found out the weak points of a scheme before others did. If he also undertook without delay what to others appeared impossible even to madness, this is explained in the history of his mission.

As he grasped the idea of showing the Jews the way to salvation from a shame of a thousand years, he knew intimately, apart from his parents, only one Jew—himself. He had, till then, no relations with the real living Hebraism. It lived in his imagination only in the incorporation of a Judas Maccabæus, Bar Kochba, Jehuda Halevy, Spinoza, Heine—the peculiarities of these men and his own at once placed him in front of all.

He assumed that all, or very many Jews, like himself, had determined no longer to bear oppression, that they had his steel will, his moral earnestness, his ideal inspiration, his unstinted unselfishness, his self-sacrifice, and he judged that these would be the means with which a statesman might work even when he had no land, no army, no fleet, and no finances at his disposition. The tragical element of his life was that in these basic calculations he was wrong. His qualities may be found