The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
104printed page
scan 42 of 62

brary of works on Palestine, the Orient and colonization. The members of the Commission gave, in various places, lectures of an instructive nature on Palestine, colonization and social science. The economic work comprised an investigation into the economic possibilities of Asia Minor and Syria. Special enquiries were made as to the feasibility of growing wool in Palestine, and the preliminary experiments have proved satisfactory. It is hoped that this may become an important factor in the economic possibilities of the country. Land was secured for experimental purposes, and the Commission advised as to the land bought for the movement. The Commission in conjunction with the Colonial Trust, took part in the formation of the Palastina-Handelsgesellschaft in Hamburg, in which the Trust participated to the extent of 22,500 marks. It also helped to promote the German-Levant Wool Company, the Trust taking shares for 25,000 marks, one of the conditions being that Jews are to be trained as wool-cultivators. The Commission is starting a society for the introduction of Jewish home industries and crafts into Palestine. It is anticipated that this undertaking will exercise an enormous influence on the economic and moral situation of the Jews in the Holy Land. Information was collected as to transport and mining undertakings, a farm was founded for Kishineff orphans, and the cultivation of olive-trees was undertaken.

Prof. Dr. Warburg appends some remarks on the report. He points out that the work of the Palestine Commission is absolutely necessary and indispensable for the movement. They must not run the risk of accepting a Charter and taking over vast obligations, the significance of which is unknown, and the conditions of which have not been previously studied. They must therefore be thoroughly acquainted and primed with all practical questions affecting Palestine. The acquisition of a Charter is more likely to be acilitated than impeded by the now possible economic

work in Palestine. The argument put forward by Mr. Zangwill that the Sultan, if people are stupid enough to work for him now, will refrain from granting them rights, is a fallacy. It would be correct if it only referred to a small territory, e. g., an estate, that was voluntarily worked without any legal contract. But the work of the Commission embraces the whole country, the work now begun being but a small proportion of the potential extent of the operations. The saying applies “Appetite comes with eating.” If the Sultan sees what the Zionists are able to do and what advantage they are to the country he will be much more accessible to their requests. They could only expect to receive a Charter when they had laid the foundations of economic work in Palestine, to which they could point to their political negotiations. As long as they merely professed good-will without being able to point to deeds, they would be preaching to deaf ears and would obtain the confidence neither of Turkey nor ofthe Great Powers. Their right to the land by reason of having nossessed it 2,000 years ago is not sufficient claim; they must create a modern title which would consist in the fact that Palestine depended economically upon the Jews, owing its progress to Jewish initiative and resources. There is no foundation for the assertion that without a Charter everything is unsafe in Palestine. The Turks will favor Jewish enterprise as long as they can do so without facilitating the invasion of any one of the Great Powers. Moreover, the movement will gain in prestige when it is seen that Zionists are capable of putting their ideas into practice. The programme in Palestine should, briefly stated, be as follows: (1) Strengthening and increase of the Jewish element in Palestine in a legal straightforward way, elevating and strengthening the Jewish population in the towns by education and the creation of industries; (2) strengthening and increase of Jewish influence in Palestine by means of the possession or control of all the more