The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
98printed page
scan 36 of 62
Facsimile · scan 36 of 62
Scan of p. 98
Text · transcribed from the scan

qualities of Palestine than of the good qualities of Uganda.

Dr. Stein, a political Zionist, said that their love for Palestine was historical, not hysterical, attacked the unfair mode of elections of which the leaders of the Zione were guilty, and read a letter to that effect from Dr. Mandelstamm. He finally said, amidst many interruptions, that in view of this fact the Extraordinary Congress was not competent to decide on the East Africa question.

Dr. Marmorek, who was in the chair, then recognized Mr. Percy Baker, who submitted the Report of the Credentials' Committee. It stated that in the examination of the mandates it found that several elections had taken place irregularly. Sometimes this had been by mistake as to the present state of the organisation regarding the necessary number of constituents for every delegate, and in other cases it was a matter of too much zeal. In Switzerland, England and America the election of delegates was carried out with exemplary care. As to the protest against elections in Russia, they had arrived too late to be considered. Three of the elections in Russia were, however, declared illegal. The Committee made a number of recommendations for the future regulation of elections to Congress.

A tumult followed the presentation of the report, which was challenged. The account which follows is taken from the London Jewish World:

Mr. Zangwill Shouldered.

The Russian opposition had previously complained bitterly of the manner in which the elections were carried out by the leaders of the Zione Zion in Russia, and alleged that the monies of the organisation had been utilised for the propagation of party purposes.

The Opposition speakers now began vio-

lently to impugn the validity of the Zione Zion elections, and one of them demanded that they should be reduced by a half. Then the Opposition called for a debate on the elections, but as this had been already reported upon by the Credentials Committee the proposition was out of order.

Finding itself in this dilemma and having nothing to lose, the opposition broke out into disorder. There arose a pandemonium. Men and women were throwing up their arms wildly and shouting hoarsely, and worked themselves into a frenzy, which nothing could calm. This demonstration was echoed by numerous visitors in the gallery and, to their mutual encouragement, those below and those upstairs roared on, waving hats and handkerchiefs. Business under such circumstances, of course, could not be proceeded with, and Dr. Alexander Marmorek, who had taken the chair in the absence of Dr. Max Nordau, gave up the hope of restoring order, and at three o'clock in the morning he suspended the sitting.

It was understood that the opposition would, as a protest, leave the Congress hall. Some of the leading stalwarts of the Zione Zion proposed to Dr. Marmorek that the Congress should nevertheless proceed with the work. To this he replied that it would be a coup d'etat and bade them good-night.

The Zione Zion, secure in their coming victory, left things to run their course, when all at once, in a dramatic manner, troops of the majority rushed upon the platform, climbing over chairs, tables and barriers. A shout of triumph then arose as soon as they were in possession. The minority meanwhile continued their uproar, and on the appearance of Mr. Zangwill and Mr. Greenberg, who entered the gallery to quiet the disturbance, they were unwillingly carried on the shoulders of the tumult makers.