The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
96printed page
scan 34 of 62
Facsimile · scan 34 of 62
Scan of p. 96
Text · transcribed from the scan

litical price of Palestine to unattainable heights. 6. My last reason is the simplest and shortest: Because East Africa is offered to us and Palestine is refused to us, and because there is no practical rival scheme before Congress. When East Africa is gone, you will be glad that the aching tooth is out, but afterwards you will remember that it was your only tooth. The British Government is the only Government in the world with which we have diplomatic relations and the severing of them will leave us poor indeed."

Sir Francis Montefiore who followed, offered determined opposition to Mr. Zangwill's resolution.

The proceedings were then interrupted by a debate upon procedure. There were 120 speakers on the list and four general reporters were suggested. Dr. Bodenheimer protested against the closure. The Rev. Dr. Samuel Daiches claimed that the Zionists should be heard at once. Dr. Syrkin demanded a full discussion without limitation of time and speakers, even though several days should be given to the Extraordinary Congress. Dr. Syrkin's proposal was at once put to the vote, and rejected by an overwhelming majority, less than 70 hands, almost exclusively in the Russian Socialist group, being held up in its favor. The result gave rise in that group to considerable uproar. During the confusion Dr. Nordau suspended the sitting until three o'clock.

On the resumption of the proceedings in the afternoon, Dr. Syrkin demanded that no vote should be taken until the Verifications Committee had again carefully gone through the mandates of the majority, as he had reason to believe that many were illegal. As the mandates of many in the minority had been annulled no favor should be shown to the majority.

Mr. M. Shire (London), in opposing Mr. Zangwill's resolution, said that if the East Africa offer were rejected, the whole English people would be grateful to them.

The argument had been used in the British Parliament that if the English had land suitable for colonization they dare not give it to others. Mr. Shire denied that there was anything magnanimous in the British Government's offer, and maintained that both political parties were using the Jews for their own purposes, as the Governments of Russia and Germany were doing in the case of the Jews in those countries. Mr. Zangwill had referred in his speech to Mr. Balfour's recent statement in the House of Commons as to the offer of land, but he had not told them that the anti-Semitic speech of Mr. Balfour had made more Zionists than Mr. Zangwill had done with all his speeches. Mr. Zangwill wanted to beg of the British Government for more; he wanted to make the Congress a King of Schnorrers.

Mr. Zangwill was permitted to make a personal statement in refutation of some utterances which Mr. Shire had attributed to him. With reference to Mr. Shire's concluding remarks Mr. Zangwill said that they were not clever enough to be Kings of Schnorrers.

Dr. Sloucz spoke on behalf of the Political Zionists and protested against the creation of groups. The political Zionists would uphold the original Basle Programme.

Mr. Joseph Cowen, who was received with cheers, said that he wanted the original Basie Programme without any alteration. He, therefore, moved the following amendment, and by voting for it he said the Congress would have that programme:—

"The Congress resolves to thank the British Government for its offer of a territory in East Africa for the purpose of a Jewish settlement. It regrets, after having sent out a commission to examine the territory, to find itself unable to undertake the formation of such a settlement. The Congress records its belief that the Zionist organization should, whenever opportuni-