The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 2 · August 1905
86printed page
scan 24 of 62
86
THE MACCABAEAN

behalf. The opponents of our movement declared with glee that Zionism had died with Herzl. We must show them that they were mistaken. We must show the world that Zionism is not a one-man movement.

"You will have to adapt the organization of our movement to the new situation created by Herzl's death. Within our own body splits have manifested themselves which seriously threaten its unity. Even while we are united we are terribly weak, and if we are also going to be torn asunder and to waste our strength in fruitless

HERZL'S GRAVE.

squabbles we shall condemn ourselves to complete impotence. Hostile parties within the Zionist movement betoken its imminent suicide—no more and no less. Since the last Congress men who, too, call themselves Zionists, have assailed our programme. They will have to declare explicitly whether the Basle programme is still the bed-rock on which we securely stand, or whether they seek to leave it partly or entirely. Sincerity towards us and the world is an elemental principle of honesty.

"The Jewish people and the world at large must not be left in doubt as to what we really want. As to the acceptance or refusal of the magnanimous offer of the British Government, you will have to decide at a special sitting which, in my opinion, in complete misunderstanding of the text and meaning of a resolution of the Sixth Congress has been given the name of an Extraordinary Congress.

"I will, therefore, not now dilate on this highly important topic. The intense but considered longing for the land of our fathers which doubtless animates every Zionist and first made him a Zionist has, among a number of our adherents, taken the form of a nervous impatience which apparently can no longer wait. And as the immediate acquisition of the land of our desire on those conditions which would alone guarantee that the return to the old home would constitute a blessing for our people, and the solution of the Jewish question, do not depend upon us, they want to return to the long since discredited method of small colonization without any publicly and legally secured basis, and without previously concluding a contract with the Government of His Majesty the Sultan. They will have to consider the vital question whether Zionism is to return to its pre-Herzlian origins, become a so-called practical Chovevi Zionism, and by a mighty effort of the whole Jewish people settle a few dozen families in Palestine as subventioned colonists, by way of consolation and hope, or whether it is to proceed on the road which Herzl hewed out for it, and remain a great political movement which will not rest until, with the consent and co-operation of the Powers, it has created normal circumstances of existence for the Jewish people, for the salvation of the one and the advantage of the other.

"I may express the hope that you in your wisdom will find a middle course which will—at any rate, partly—satisfy the im-