Commission left England for British East Africa. Sir Harry Johnson—at one time High Commissioner of the Protectorate— has taken great interest in the proposed Concession, and has placed at our disposal much valuable advice and assistance. He suggested, inter alia, a slight deviation from the Government’s offer as being for many reasons preferable. Both Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch appear, from the reports they sent, to have been under the impression that Sir Harry Johnson’s suggested deviation was an amended offer on the part of H. M. Government. As the references to such a supposed amended offer would have led to considerable confusion, they have been omitted from their reports. Needless to say, the omissions do not affect in the slightest the conclusions at which they arrive. Major Gibbons and Mr. Kaiser accompanied their reports with a large number of photographs. I regret it was not possible to publish all of them; a selection of them are reproduced. In accordance with arangement, the reports of Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch were sent for perusal to Major Gibbons as leader of the Commission, and he has added to his report a supplement containing observations upon the reports of his two colleagues. It would be out of place for me here to venture any opinion I may have formed, from a study of the reports as they passed through my hands, as to the utility of the territory offered us for the purpose of a Jewish Settlement. The matter is one presumably for Congress, which, I suppose, will have placed before it the recommendations of the “Actions” Committee upon the whole. scheme. But in any final decision that may be arrived at, due regard will, I doubt not, be had to the conditions upon which the scheme could alone be acceptable, which Dr. Herzl set forth in a letter to Sir Francis Montefiore, under date of 14th December, 1903. In the course of that letter he said:—"To my minds four elements are necessary for our deeming within the range of practical politics the
suggestion of the British Government:—(1) The territory has to be sufficiently extensive to admit of an immigration of such a character as should be eventually a material relief to the pressure that to-day exists in Eastern Jewry; (2) It follows that the territory has to be one colonisable by such people as ours; (3) the Concession has to be invested with such autonomous rights as would ensure the Jewish character of the settlement; and (4), perhaps governing all, the enthusiasm of our own people in respect to the offer has to be of such a nature as will overcome all the obvious conditions will be bound to arise in the creation of the settlement." The Reports now presented will supply the means of determining to what extent some of these four conditions, which were previously in doubt, are likely to be fulfilled in the territory now reported upon.
At the nroper time, I am sure the opportunity will be taken of recording appreciation of the manner in which the Commissioners have performed their work. But it is only right here to note, that Mr. Wilbusch undertook his arduous task of assisting to examine the territory and presenting his report without any fee, and soleIy with the desire of serving the Zionist Organization, of which he ıs an earnest and loyal supporter. Finally, I wish to express my sense of the deep obligations we are under to Sir Clement Hill—until lately Chief of the Protectorate Department— and the other officials of the Foreign Office for constant courtesy and kindly attention evinced from the very inception of the offer by H. M. Government.
Obediently yours,
LEOPOLD J. GREENBERG.
16th May, 1905.
Plan of the Commission.
Major Gibbons at the outset mentions that the extent of country surveyed was limited, owing to his colleagues being unprovided with survey instruments. Traveling, he says, was particularly arduous and
