The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
4printed page
scan 8 of 72

The East African Report.

A Jewish "Blue Book."

In August of 1903, a leading Zionist, by no means in sympathy with the East African scheme, seeing the document in which the British Government made that offer, involuntarily recited the old Jewish blessing for the First Fruits. Though it dooms the scheme, many. no doubt, will be equally ready to repeat that blessing on opening what is'the first Jewish Blue Book. Printed in the same form as all British Government papers issued, with the motto and sign of Zionism on the cover, the “Report of the work of the commission sent out by the Zionist organization to examine the territory offered by H. M. Government to the organization for the purpose of a Jewish settlement in British East Africa,” makes eurious reading. The “spies” in the persons of Major A. St. H. Gibbons, Professor Alfred Kaiser and N. Wilbusch, report that there are giants in the land, nature's giants, unfertility from an agricultural point of view, and lack of raw material for industrial development, and, therefore, unlike the Exodic story, there will be no second or minority report on the subject.

The story of the expedition is marred by the divergence of opinion that prevailed amongst the members of the commission, or rather between Major Gibbons, the head of the expedition, and Mr. Wilbusch, who is a Russian Zionist, and whose report Major Gibbons deals with in the most critical terms. We are, unfortunately for our colleague, led on the internal evidence of his report, to conclude that he was unqualified for his task, and that, on the whole, his participation in this historic expedition has been in the nature of a disservice rather than of service to the Jews. His report is jejune on the face of it and his diary in its frankness betrays his lack of ability to recognize the character of

the task before him. Mr. Greenberg seeks to excuse Mr. Wilbusch because he labored without pay; this hardly compensates us for the lack of capability this honorary investigator puts upon us.

The Blue Book which is issued both in English and German, is illustrated with maps and photographs and opens with the following letter by Mr. L. J. Greenberg:

Herzl's Ambition.

To the members of the "Actions" Committee of the Zionist Organization.

Gentlemen—Herewith I have the honour of transmitting to you the Reports of Major Gibbons and Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch, who in December last proceeded to British East Africa to examine the territory offered by H. M. Government to the Zionist Organization for the purposes of a Jewish Settlement. The suggestion originally made by H. M. Government was that we should send to British East Africa a Commission to confer with the authorities there, with a view to determining what part, if any, of the Protectorate was available for the purposes of a Jewish settlement, and to report generally upon its suitability and prospects. Dr. Herzl, however, preterred that H. M. Government should offer a definite territory, and this they did, after communication with the High Commissioner, in January last year. The territory is denominated on the accompanying map. Dr. Herzl deemed it desirable, before proceeding further, to lay before the "Actions" Committee, which met early in last year, the definite proposal of H. M. Government, and it was then decided that the Commission of Inquiry should be forthwith organized. Dr. Herzl, however, fell ill soon after the meeting of the "Actions" Committee. This, and still more, his ever-to-be-deplored death, naturally delayed the matter. Hence it was that only so recently as last December the