The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
20printed page
scan 24 of 72
20
THE MACCABAEAN

wildest dreams, ever soberly comtemplate the development of a plan having for its purpose the colonization of Jews into a political or even spiritual Zion. The movement under the leadership of Theodor Herzl had attained a following of enthusiasts of no mean number for Herzl, though an exceptional man—one of those splendid characters whom the world produces at exceedingly rare intervals—was nevertheless, as he has frequently been described, a dreamer; and by the very strength of his nature he brought within the circle of his influence many who were as visionary as was he himself. For those who had builded upon Theodor Herzl’s success, his death was a sad blow—a sad blow because many of the dreamers who have essayed to carry forward the plans of Herz! are dreamers of a more materialistic kind....

"Jews throughout the world have had much to contend with. Anti-Semitic outbreaks have for centuries made their lives miserable and in some of the less civilized though highly Christianized countries their sufferings have been well nigh unendurable; but is this an excuse for a Zionistic State? No, a thousand times, no. In this country, and we believe it may, with equal truth be said of Great Britain, men and women of Jewish faith dislike to read in the columns of their favorite newspaper that Miss or Mr. So-and-So, a Jew or Jewess. was a member of this or that committee or attended this or that function. They dislike it because they feel that as men and women, actuated by the same impulses, swayed by the same emotions, living under the same canopy, there should be no occasion to single them out from others of different religious beliefs; and they are right. What, then, is the trend of Zionism—a Jewish State? God forbid!"

It is needless for your committee to characterize the logic of this opposition. Still the American does not object to printing Zionist news. Its space is, however, very limited. It is now made up mainly of clippings from other Jewish papers, but it does not object to Zionist clippings.

* JEWISH COMMENT, Baltimore Md.—The editor of this paper, from numberless evidences is Louis H. Levin. The Comment has always been a fair, independent critic of the

movement and has not hesitated to endorse various phases of the principles of our propaganda. It has published by far the best Zionist articles that have yet appeared in the American Jewish press. Among its contributors are many Zionists.

* JEWISH CONSERVATOR, Chicago, Ill.—The editors of this paper were, until recently, a few young rabbis of the city of Chicago. The editorial opinions are few and far between. Thev Aare antı-Zıonistie on the missinn hasis.

* JEwISH CRITERION, Pittsburg, Pa.—The editors of this paper are the Rev. J. Leonard Levy and Charles H. Joseph. Circulating in so active a Zionist center, and being edited by eminently fair men, the Criterion is a good record of the doings of our movement. The Rev. Mr. Levy is not strenuously opposed to Zionism. In fact he had agreed, when our convention was held in Pittsburg, to speak at our mass-meeting. He believes in a protesting sort of a way in the “Israel’s mission is peace” idea, and prides himself on his liberality and broadmindedness. Editorials are signed in the Criterion. Mr. Joseph’s treatment of Zionism is mildly expostulatory. He has no fault to find with the Zionists for doing what they are doing. He comments fairly, however, upon all Zionist developments. The Criterion is in the making, and with the growth of the movement in Pittsburg, we hope to find the Criterion even less remonstrative than heretofore.

* EMANUEL, San Francisco, Cal.—The editor of Emanuel is Dr. Jacob Voorsanger. Dr. Voorsanger is opposed to Zionism, though he has, more than once, expressed his approval of the enthusiasm of our adherents. He is opposed to political Zionism. He believes the Jews should be united on religious grounds; he is a rabbi of the German reform school. He believes in Hebraic culture, for he is a Hebrew scholar, but he desires to utilize that culture in the strengthening of the Jewish religion. Emanuel gives fair notices of Zionist events. It has a limited circulation among Zionists. It reprints many articles from the columns of its eastern contemporaries.

* THE JEWISH GAZETTE.—A Yiddish and English weekly edition of the Jewish Daily