The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
19printed page
scan 23 of 72

at once to the word "Jew" or "Zion," when he reads them in books of quite a foreign make?

The socialists of New York began their campaign with a firm opinion in favor of the universality of their movement. They “brothered” it with their German comrade:s. They felt that the Jew must find relief in the establishment of the co-operative commonwealth. Asa logical consequence, they hated all things Jewish .and their lives had been saturated with Jewish tradit'oi:s and learning. They repudiated all that in favor of a newer brotherhood, from which they expected very much. That was the time when socialists would bombard the heavens on the Day of Atonement to exemplify their disbelief in God. The times have produced manv chanses. but the most

notable is the charge that the Vorwaeris, the socialist daily, has become even more Jewish than the accepted defender of orthodox Judaism in New York, the Jewish Daily News. The more radical socialists have a grievance against the Vorwaerts; it it t00o Jewish. It does not now oppose Jewish traditions; it uses them in its propoganda. And a large wing of socialists have openly gone over to Zionism, with the thought that Socialism must find its expression so far as Jews are concerned in a Jewish state. Socialism has turned away from a universal emancipation. Jewish sncialists have returned to the Jewish peopie, with whom they find themselves more in harmony. The Jew in the socialist has won the hattle.

GERSONI.

The Jewish Press on Zionism.

The purpose of this summary is to present an accurate statement of the opinions of American Jewish weeklies on Zionism. Its aim is to benefit our movement by presenting such a summary as will be of practical value in our propaganda work in so far as it may effect the Jewish press.

Those opinions marked with a * were compiled from the reading of editorials of the weeklies there under discussion. Those opinions marked with a † were summarized from letters addressed to our Organization Committee, in the columns of those weeklies or direct.

*BOSTON ADVOCATE, Boston, Mass.—The Advocate is a new paper. It seems to be the successor of the Jewish Home Journal, which was formerly the Mt. Sinai Monthly. Its editor seems to be Mr. J. Lyons, who is an ardent Boston Zionist. The Rev. J. Landau, formerly of Australia, now of Boston, is a frequent contributor. The paper seems to be Zionistic.

† JEWISH AMERICAN, Detroit, Mich.—The editor of this paper is the Rev. Leo M. Frank-

lin, a graduate of the Hebrew Union College. He is opposed to the Zionist movement, as the subjoined editorial shows:

"That there may be no room for doubt as to the position of The Jewish American let it be understood that it is utterly and irrevocably opposed to the movement, in whatever phase it has been or may yet be presented. Political Zionism —the Uganda project and spiritual Zionism—are the trinity of means by which singly or en masse the leaders of the movement hope to secure a sufficient following to enable them to establish a State or, if Uganda, a colony with home rule under the suzerainty of Great Britain. Failing in this, they offer as a compromise, spiritual Zionism, or the influence of their combined efforts in an endeavor to send those of their brethren less fortunately situated to some out of the way country, with the same purpose in view. It is difficult to understand how any one of Jewish faith who has lived in America for a length of time could fail to at least partially appreciate the manifold blessings of our system of government. It is even more difficult to comprehend how he could, even in his