The Maccabaean · Vol. IX, No. 1 · July 1905
17printed page
scan 21 of 72
THE MACCABAEAN
17

desolate as a country ever was; the farmers of East Africa would still feel that it was greatly to their disadvantage if an area of 5,000 square miles were given gratis to a corporation consisting mostly of foreigners. They would fear the competition of the Jews more if they came as an association than if they were scattered as individual persons and individual business men. This feeling induced the Planters' Union to raise a protest against the granting of the Guas Ngishu Plateau to Jews, and I have heard many speak of the undertaking in the same spirit. Many also fear the immigration of poor people which would overrun the whole country if they cannot earn their living in the territory.

Summary

In conclusion, Prof. Kaiser pronounces an exceedingly unfavourable opinion of the whole East African scheme. Economic conditions on the Guas Ngishu Plateau, he says, are so unfavourable that a portion of the immigrants would certainly leave the country again, and there would thus never be a real colonising association which could work successfully. "The immigration," he concludes, "would cost millions, and the actual usefulness of the whole scheme would be totally out of proportion to the labour expended. I consider the territory extremely unsuitable for a purely Jewish settlement, be it carried on by a co-operative association, or through private enterprise, and equally unsuitable for a mixed settlement administered through a chartered company. If Jewish capital, Jewish labour, and Jewish blood is to serve

the Zionist idea, a more promising country must be found, not a land so remote from all communication with the rest of the world, that makes such heavy demands on the settlers, and is so little fitted to consolidate the bonds uniting Jews."

Mr. Wilbusch's Report.

Mr. Wilbusch's detailed report is uncompromisingly hostile. Although, he says, it was absolutely impossible to explore the whole country in just four weeks, and to arrive at any definite conclusion, yet he was able, after a short time, to come to a fairly correct conclusion with reference to the land he was exploring, for, owing to its uniformly waste and desert character, there was unfortunately little to be found or to investigate. "Our reports," he says, "can, as a matter of fact, only show many proofs of the unsuitability of the country for cultivation and purposes of emigration, as well as the absence of all natural resources and raw materials at the present time, and the unsuitability for building purposes in the future." Mr. Wilbusch finds fault with the "impracticable and faulty organisation (of the expedition), especially the want of any means of transport." He admits that there is much in his report that is superficial, and states that, in addition to the technical questions and industrial possibilities with which he was specially charged, he touches upon other questions, such as the quality of the soil, agriculture, etc. These questions, he says, he studied himself so far as his knowledge as the son of a Russian landed proprietor allowed.