The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
254printed page
scan 30 of 56
254
THE MACCABAEAN

Dubnow himself, as has been alluded to before, considers his theory of Jewish Nationalism a synthesis between Assimilation and Zionism, combining the merits and avoiding the defects of both. But placing the center of his theory in the conception of a National Judaism, he is naturally more favorably inclined towards Zionism, which presents this conception in an inaccurate shape, than to Assimilation, which denies this idea altogether. Yet, in spite of his sympathies, his opposition to Zionism is well-defined. In two "Letters" especially devoted to this purpose, and in several passages in his other "Letters," he tries to explain and justify his negative attitude toward Zionism. His argumentation can be condensed in the following two considerations: First, the ideal of Zionism is unnecessary, since Jewish Nationalism, being of a purely spiritual nature, needs no territory of its own. Zionism like paganism of old cannot conceive a lofty abstract idea without embodying it in an idol. Secondly, Zionism is impossible, since its ideal can never be realized. As to the latter objection, the impracticability of Zionism, I think it will never be refuted by arguments but only by facts, and it will last so long as Zionism does not throw off its "ism" and become Zion. As to the former argument, the superfluousness of a separate territory for the Jews, I am sure its falsehood can be convincingly demonstrated. But I have no intention whatever to enter here into the field of Zionist polemics. This lecture, though arranged through the mediation of the Propaganda Committee of the Federation of American Zionists, does not pursue any Zionist tendencies. Zionism is not the narrow program of a party, but a whole Weltanschauung, which can be acquired only after long mental and psy-

chological endeavors. I do not believe in Zionists who are conquered by a single lecture, and bitter experiences of late with easily-gained Zionists have made us more sceptical than ever in this respect. Zionism, first of all, is based unconditionally on the recognition of National Judaism, and I frankly confess, the Jews who acknowledge the necessity and legality of a genuine development of the Jewish national spirit, but do not care for a separate territory, are more sympathetic to me than the Zionists who accentuate the necessity of a territory, but only as a Nachtasyl, and do not care for the national spirit. The purpose of this lecture will therefore be successfully achieved if it will lead some of you to consider and a few of you to acknowledge the theory of Jewish Nationalism in the form given it by Dubnow. This theory is perhaps not altogether new. I should not wonder, if many of you will tell me afterwards that they always felt the same way. But it is the merit of a theory that it raises our unconscious feelings to conscious ideas, and in this new shape transforms them into powerful agencies in life. The doctrine of Jewish Nationalism, if duly recognized, will be of great benefit both to Jews and non-Jews. By declaring the Jews to be a nation it purifies the Jewish atmosphere of the stifling church air which deadens every fresh immediate impulse, and places our activity in the broad daylight of national life. By exactly stating the relationship between nationality and citizenship it gives us that frankness and uprightness which is inseparable from manhood and dignity. But Jewish Nationalism will also be of benefit to our neighbors. I have to lay stress on this point, since it has particularly convincing force for the Jewish mind. The Jews are extravagantly al-