The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
253printed page
scan 29 of 56
Facsimile · scan 29 of 56
Scan of p. 253
Text · transcribed from the scan

tending towards the common national family, and advocating its interests, can at the same time partake in the political life of the country and devote itself to its interests, provided, of course, the Jews are completely equal in their rights with the other portions of the population. Thus the Jews all over the world do not form a state in a state, but a nation among nations, an historico-spiritual nation among the political nations."

"Since the epoch of the first emancipation of 1791, we have been fighting only for our civil rights in the European countries. Now the time has come to claim also our national rights, which, as has been shown before, are in complete accord with the legal position, as citizens, of various portions of the Jewish nation in Christian countries. The historico-spiritual Nationalism of the Jews has in its inner essence no aggressive, but an exclusively defensive tendency. What we demand is but a respectful attitude towards our national personality, towards our religion, our historical traditions, the best features of our national life. We claim that right of a genuinely independent development of our inner life which has been conceded to all other politically dependent nations."

These are in short the leading thoughts of Dubnow's theory of Jewish Nationalism as far as they are laid down in the first two fundamental "Letters on Ancient and Modern Judaism." In the following "Letters" Dubnow tries to show how these thoughts have to be applied in practice. He demands that our education be conducted on such lines that it may not, as it does now, make the Jew spiritually and culturally a stranger to his own people, but it should harmoniously meet both the national and the civil wants of the

Jew, and he requires that wherever the Jews are kept back from carrying out this purpose, they should establish national schools of their own. He advocates a separate political Jewish party in those countries in which all the other nationalities are equally organized, and he quotes with evident satisfaction the half sarcastie, half contemptuous words of Mark Twain addressed to a Jewish lawyer in Austria who had boasted of the Jews’ being the only nationality of the Austrian Empire which has no political party of its own. In short, he insists that all our national activity should be ruled by the prineiple of Autonomism, t.e., of a genuine autonomous Jewish life as far as it is in agreement with the political life of the country. I would largely exceed the limits of a lecture if I were to go into further details, and I must confine myself to these few meagre indications of the practical consequences of his theory. I should like only to add in general that the ideas of Dubnow, which at the time they were first uttered had a purely academie character, have assumed enormous actual importance in the recent turn in Russian political life. The representatives of the new movement expressly advocate the inner freedom of every nationality living on Russian territory, and the Jews, though still deprived of their primitive human rights, demand not only their rights as men and citizens, but openly and manfully present their claims on an independent existence and development as a nationality.*

* As an example—unum pro multo—I may mention the fact that at the convention of Russian journalists which took place in St. Petersburg on April 18-21, 1905, the following resolution, moved by the representative of the Russian-Jewish paper Voskhod, was unanimously adopted: “ The convention thinks it necessary to expressly demand equal civil and political rights for the Jews, and also the right of the Jewish people on culturo-national self-determination.— as, for instance, the freedom of the school, of communal self-rule, and of the national language "