The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
250printed page
scan 26 of 56

and territorial integrity,—such a nationality has attained the highest degree of national evolution. It is a sharply marked collective individuality which cannot be discolored. A fluid body needs a vessel from which it receives its shape. But the same fluid having become hardened and crystallized has no need of any vessel.”

To this class of highly developed nations belong the Jews. The racial characteristics are visible in the early period of its development, in the times of the Patriarchs and the Judges. The political elements come into prominence in the period of the Kings and —after a long interval— in the age of the Maccabaeans. But at the same time the spiritual character of the Jewish nation is fully emphasized by the prophets. Having lost their political independence, the Jews have been held together exclusively by spiritual ties, and the efficiency of these ties has been proved by the experience of two thousand years. “We are the members of a particular historico-spiritual nation which has shown its ability to get along without political independence. We are bound together by something which is stronger than political unity, by the unity of origin, by common historical evolution, common traditions, recollections of the past, hopes for the future—in short, common individual traits and feelings characterizing the indivisible entity called Jewry. “In the course of centuries, as generation followed generation, similarity of historical fortunes produced a mass of similar impressions which have crystallized, and have thrown off the deposit that may be called ‘the Jewish national soul.’ ” * History has created a certain spiritual ground under our feet. Further developing upon this

ground we shall continue to be a nation full of original creative powers. Breaking away from this ground we shall be losing our individuality and that full power of productivity which is inherent in every plant only in its natural soil.”

“Accordingly, the Jews form a nation which is endeavoring to preserve its individuality and originality. Having, however, been long deprived of one of the material requisites of a nation—the unity of the state—the Jewish nation in distinction from others has to be recognized as an historico-spiritual nation. The lack of a substantial political element in Jewish nationalism is not a sign of its weakness, but of its extraordinary power. A national unity maintaining itself without the cuticle of political independence for so long a period as two thousand years, and under the most unfavorable conditions besides—such a unity has to be declared firm and unshakable.”

But is Jewish Nationalism compatible with the fact of the Jews’ residing among other nations? Is the idea of a separate Jewish nationality not in contradiction with the citizenship of the Jews in the different states?

In discussing this question, Dubnow is fully aware of touching the vital point of his whole theory. The solution which he offers to this grave problem is most brilliant and enticing.

The assumption that the Jews, while forming a distinctly separate nationality, cannot be at the same time loyal citizens of their respective states, rests on a grave error which is extremely dangerous, namely, the identification of state and nationality. In former times the state was identified with religion, one religion assuming the part of a "ruling church," while all the other forms of religion were more or less cruelly oppressed. The disas-

*Dubnow, Jewish History, Philadelphia, 1903, p. 28.