The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
247printed page
scan 23 of 56
THE MACCABAEAN
247

which was issued by the Jewish Publication Society a few years ago, and has had considerable success in this country, by far more than the German translation had previously met with in Germany. I would like to mention in passing that both as an historian and a writer Dubnow occupies a commanding position in the Russian literature of the Jews. He has published numerous contributions of sreat scientific value to the history of the Jews, and is now issuing a large volume on Jewish history. But though occupied with the past of the Jews,- Dubnow at the same time eagerly watches the Jewish present, and his numerous articles on burning Jewish questions, which he examines with the far-reaching, unbiased eve of the historian, belong to the best that has ever been produced along this ine in any language. His views on Jewsh Nationalism—the subject of this lec- (ure—are but lightly touched upon in the Iittle English volume mentioned before, but they are fully and elaborately developed in an entire series of articles which appeared between 1897 and 1902 ın the Russian-Jewish Monthly “Voskhod,” under the title, “Letters on Ancient and Modern Judaism.” The following exposition of his theory is mostly derived from these letters, but in order to condense it and make it more transparent, I shall try to handle the matter as independently and unconstrainedly as possible.

The name which Dubnow assigns to his theory is "Spiritual Nationalism,"—and in these two words he gives us in a nutshell the leading thoughts of his doctrine, and clearly defines its position relative to the other solutions of the Jewish problem. "Nationalism" defines the Jews as a nation which is separated or rather differentiated from all the other nations and claims an independent national develop-

ment of its own. The attribute "spiritual" specializes the Jews, in distinction from all other nations, as one which is kept together solely by spiritual means and therefore needs no territory nor other political agencies for its existence. The former contains the protest against Assimilation; the latter marks the opposition to Zionism.

Let us examine a little more closely the views indicated by these two words.

By hoisting the flag of Jewish Nationalism, Dubnow declares his protest not only against the theory of Assimilation but also against that other view mentioned before, declaring the Jews to constitute a mere religious community and, with regard to national affinity, to belong to the respective nationalities among which they live. In his "Letters" Dubnow dwells at length on this view and tries to refute it in detail. If I were delivering this lecture in Germany or in a country influenced by German thought, I would be compelled to devote a great deal of attention to this question, in view of the fact that the conception of the Jews as a religious community, created in Germany by Moses Mendelssohn, has still a large number of ardent champions in Europe. But here in America, and especially in this city, where members of all the nationalities of the world live peaceably together, and where the Jew who feels tempted to attach himself to a non-Jewish nationality has the embarrassing choice of all possible nationalities, from the big-bodied Irishman down to the pig-tailed Chinese, ext_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text_text and the Jews have to acknowledge their own nationality against their will.

But is Nationalism in general and Jewish Nationalism in particular compatible with the highest ideals of morality, with the universal brotherhood of man? An objeetion of this kind can often be heard