endeavors towards "converting" their neighbors to the principles of which they are the only legitimate guardians.
This doctrine has numerous adherents on both sides of the Atlantic. Still, I frankly confess that it costs me a great strain to speak about it seriously. To begin with: this belief has no root whatsoever in the Jewish past. It is true, the Jewish mission, or rather the expectation that the principles of the Jewish Religion will extend their influence over the non-Jewish world, is often spoken of in the literature of the Jews, but never with the addition that to this end the Jews have to give up their own national centre. The prophets to whom the champions of the mission theory refer with special fondness were the greatest patriots of the Jewish land, and the Great Unknown Prophet who most of all proclaims the idea of a Jewish mission, pictures in the most tender and enthusiastic terms the return of the Jewish people to its old home. Of course, the late origin of a theory is in itself no final indictment against its correctness. But there is another fact which is even more apt to raise our suspicions, I mean that most significant fact, that the theory of a Jewish mission is entirely unknown in those countries where the Jews still live a genuine Jewish life and cling with all their might to Judaism, but is altogether limited in its influence to Western Europe and America, where the Jews have more or less loosed the ties connecting them with their nationality and, instead of being the missionaries and teachers of the nations around them, have become their most docile and submissive pupils. It is an easy thing to show the entire hollowness of the logical foundation upon which this belief rests. But it is not necessary. I have simply to point out one fact,
which deals the death blow to the whole theory. A doctrine or a conception may often seem questionable and unfounded from an objective point of view. But the convincing power it has with its adherents, the influence it exercises upon their minds and consequently in one way or the other upon their lives, justify it subjectively. It may not be true as a logical idea. It becomes true as a psychological conviction. But does the theory of the Jewish mission, which lays upon the shoulders of the Jews the most difficult task ever undertaken by any nation, exert any influence upon the activity of the individual Jew or of the Jews as a whole? I think I need not answer this question. You may use a microscope for your investigation, and you will discover not even the faintest trace of any living effect of the doctrine of a Jewish mission, except in some meaningless outpourings in the pulpit or in the still more meaningless phrases in our newspapers. A theory which is so absolutely barren, which has utterly failed to lay hold on its own adherents, and cannot even claim the justification of a deep conviction, is doomed of itself, and cannot be reckoned among the attempts to solve problems of actual life. But, however baseless and fruitless this theory may be in itself, it is extremely valuable to us as a symptom, showing the great, the burning need for a doctrine which will reconcile the Jew to his present position among the nations.
The first serious attempt to satisfy this burning need is, as far as I can see, the theory of Jewish Nationalism propounded by the man whose name is mentioned in the title of this lecture—by S. M. Dubnow.
Dubnow, I hope, is no stranger to you. Most of you have probably read his brilliant little pamphlet on Jewish history
