The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 6 · June 1905
245printed page
scan 21 of 56
THE MACCABAEAN
245

side of, praying and studying, it tries to reach its aim by more worldly means, by a Congress, a Colonial Trust, a National Fund, an elaborate organization. But, like the old Messianism, it makes the Jewish present tolerable by deriving courage and comfort from the Jewish past and looking for compensation and reward toward a Jewish future.

Diametrically opposed to Zionism, both in its ancient and modern shape, is the theory of Assimilation. In one respect, however, it agrees with Zionism, namely, in considering the existence of the Jews among the nations an anomaly which has to be disposed of. But according to this theory there is no need to go to Palestine in order to solve the problem. It can very well be done on the spot. The Jews have but to give up their national individuality, to assimilate themselves to the nation among which they live and thus entirely disappear from the face of the earth. There are numerous forms of this doctrine of Assimilation, some of them trying to conceal the ultimate goal. But whether they consciously or unconsciously deny it, at the bottom of all of them lies the idea of the complete decomposition of Judaism.

Both the theory of Zionism and the theory of Assimilation, if carried out in practice, present radical and the only logical solutions of the problem of Judaism. In spite of this, or rather, as we shall soon find out, owing to this, neither of them can boast of having taken a firm grasp on the Jewish people. Their strength—in being radical and logical—has become their weakness. For human life is not regulated by logical considerations, but by psychological needs. Assimilation proposes to give up the Jewish individuality, but the bulk of our people has still a deeply rooted Jewish consciousness

sometimes unconsciousness. Zionism recommends to the Jews to leave the nations among which they live and make themselves independent—but the Jew of to-day is too intimately connected with the life and activities of his neighbors to be able to renounce them. Jewry is dangerously ill: Assimilation recommends suicide, Zionism recommends transportation to a healthy climate. But the patient has still too much vitality to commit suicide and too little energy to bear transportation. The only remedy he will be ready to accept is that which will not take him out of his place, and still enable him to keep up his life. In other words, the only theory which in the present stage of Jewish development is likely to meet with striking success among large numbers of our people is a compromising solution which, declaring the Jewish Golus a normal condition, will allow them to maintain their present relations to their neighbors, and at the same time preserve their Jewish individuality,—to remain “among the nations,” but still continue to be an “Israel.”

An attempt towards this end has inmod- ern times been undertaken by a theory known under the name of “Jewish mission.” This theory, usually associated with the opinion that the Jews are no nation but merely a religious community, passionately denies that the Golus is an anomaly. It is, on the contrary, bent on considering it a benefit for which the Jews have to be grateful to their Maker. God has scattered the Jews all over the world not as a punishment for their sins, but as a reward for their religious superiority, in order to be missionaries to all the nations of the world and to teach them the lofty truths of pure Monotheism and Morality. By virtue of their mission the Jews have to remain in exile and direct their