The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
185printed page
scan 9 of 54

brew Union College will protestingly bow, and yield. And yet the decision of the anti-theological head of a theological institution can not pass entirely unchallenged. Our vagrant thoughts favor this same synod because we hope something for a less peripatetic Judaism than that which is offered us on every hand.

The "odium theologium" is as much upon Prof. Schechter as an ordinator of rabbis as upon the Rabbis themselves, so that he does not stand in the free position of the outsider, who has an imperative exclamation at his command wherewith to condemn theology. A synod, says the professor, may yield us a denial of positive Judaism in order to make way for a less positive insubstantial Christianity. We dearly wish a synod would declare just such ideas —the Jewish awakening would follow like a bolt from the blue, and a real Judaism would spring up in a night with thousands and tens of thousands of enthusiasts to protest against the synodic betrayal of Israel. Thousands of Jews to whom religion is a matter of no importance would rally to the standard if Judaism were menaced in such fashion.

If the head of the Jewish Pre-synodic Theological Seminary ever Thought. seriously takes in hand the task of creating a Jewish revival the beginning of that task must be the demonstration of the concensus of anti-Jewish ideas which animate and guide the modern American Rabbinate. Until that is done no one will feel that Judaism is in great danger.

What Prof Schechter does not realize is that it is the mode to say things rather than to mean them. Nine out of ten of the observations that trouble him are not intended to stand the test of criticism

or analysis. Irresponsibility has begot carelessness, and in a dull world a wild non-Jewish phrase makes a week's good gossip, which is a boon in many a center of Jewish life. The law is what men make it not what is written. No one would heed a synodical definition of Judaism if he did not agree with it, even if he gave it public respect. So we are not afraid of a catechistic Judaism even of the wilder sort, but the synod would prick the bubble of much rhetoric —it would necessitate an inter-criticism amongst the Rabbis, out of which the poor laymen might gather a few valuable and positive ideals such as do constitute a real Judaism. That attained the synod might fade in the hands of a commission charged with the task of defining Judaism.

In other words it is not the synod, but what the attempt to create it might yield that has our friendship and support.

To the careful student of Jews in Jewish history there is unNew York. doubtedly something piquant in the celebration of the 250th anniversary of the settlement of the Jews in New York. Kayserling has fairly successfully demonstrated that a Jew set foot on American soil as soon as, if not sooner than Columbus himself. But then the Jew lost his foothold as it were, and did not turn up again till half of the seventeenth century had been spent and there the record is established by the fact that the twenty-seven Jews who arrived in the barque St. Catarina from Bahia were hauled before the court for not having paid the balance of their passage money.

The story of the settlement as told by Judge Daly is not without its grim humor. The governor of the New Netherlands, Stuyvesant, was hostile to the