have already mentioned, counts 160 Hebrew and Jewish authorities on geography and travel literature, and this includes the Bible and the whole of the Pentateuchal and Rabbinic writings. If we added fifty volumes of fair inmportance for all that has been written since Zunz drew up his schedule we shall have fairly covered the ground.
The writer once calculated that day by day, year by year, two volumes are published concerning the Holy Land, and though the Jews have done more in the last ten years than in a previous century in this department of literature, it still remains a fact, that in the literature as in all other things connected with Palestine—excepting Chaluka—the non-Jews carry off the palm. Exactly why this is the case is beyond our explanation.
MR. ZANGWILL, who de- Books claims somewhat against Needed. the Jewish proneness to literary activity, might well try and work out the real question: Why is the Jewish literary activity so small in those departments in which other peoples establish records. Not that we are really looking for a collection of tourists' books by Jews on lines similar to those which perplex the ordinary reviewer each season. The book made by a Cook's tourist flying somewhat slower but with the pace eagerness of a swallow, is as a rule an infinitely poorer publication than the regular guide book, which, if less fanciful, is at least more reliable.
But we think that there should be room for books on the world as the leisured Jew sees it, and still more should there be a hearty welcome for "Israel under all climes," as observed by capable and studious Jews. In fact, there is need for some compendium that shall tell us in a
summary how we stand to-day in all the quarters of the globe.
Ix a travelled world few In the Jews have travelled so Jew- East. ishly as he from London to Bokhara and back, and yet at the same time he has turned out but an indifferent book of travels. In fact, he has reprinted the sketches he wrote at different times for current periodicals, so that he presents us with thumb-nail pictures from a tourist's note-book. But from his doubts as to Sodom and Gomorrah being covered by the Dead Sea, to his pieture of the Chassidim dancing around the Brisker Rav on Simchas Torah, the book carries us through perennially interesting Jewish scenes. We may quote one paragraph: “Jaffa has become almost a Hebrew port. The shop fronts are crowned by Hebrew names and sign-posts. The market is a Jewish forum, and the very infants speak Bible Hebrew. There are few things more touching to the Jew returning to the land of his forefathers than to find his little co-religionists doing their lessons in Hebrew, aye, prattling in it, as a very living language—the language of play.” This is the first such report in a Jewish book of travel. All our older records of those who went out to spy the land found it the very reverse of a Jewish land. Behind these few phrases there is the story of a great upheaval in the mental attitude of the Jew in Palestine and a storv of hope for the Jewish future.
FEW of us—and who is Professor Schechter. not timid in this generation—will care to cross swords with Prof. Schechter in a field peculiarly his own. When he says that a synod is a dangerous thing, we imagine that even the Cincinnati He-