The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
214printed page
scan 38 of 54
Facsimile · scan 38 of 54
Scan of p. 214
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabæan

Editorial Pages. J. de Haas, Editor.

THERE will be more than East Africa one view of the present poAgain. sition of the Zionist movement within the Zionist ranks, and there are a variety of opinions without. Some men, however, never change, and amongst these is Mr. Claude G. Montefiore. At one time his "bete noir" was Palestine, now it is any autonomous condition for the Jews, even in British East Africa. If there is modification, there is no change in that opinion, Mr. Montefiore is convinced that no good can come out of Zionist effort. The Actions Committee invited the Anglo-Jewish Association to participate in a conference on the East African proposition. The Czar of Assimilation endeavored to crack over the heads of his otherwise loyal legionaries the whip of the I. C. A., but the members of the A. J. A. were afraid to obey for fear of London sentiment, and their rebellion has the support of the Jewish Chronicle, which at times has had both its apostle and inspiration in Mr. Montefiore.

It is frankly true that seeing Mr. Montefiore is seriously opposed to the possible Jewish autonomous settlement in East Africa, we begin to feel that it is our bounden duty to recommend a plan on which we have been heretofore as neutral as possible. There must be something valuable from the Zionist point of view in the scheme else it would not meet with the Montefiorian contempt, and the objections of that new and zealous con-

vert to assimilation, Lucien Wolf. As neither of these gentlemen could prevail, the Anglo-Jewish Association is pledged to a very slippery resolution, which even the Chronicle cannot interpret, to attend the conference. If some other bodies attend that conference guided by equally virile and intelligible mandates we shall much regret the postage stamps spent in convening it.

Indeed, the whole plan has pained us deeply. After the conduct of the I. C. A. in 1903, it was clearly the business of the Actions Committee to take no public step which was not fully warranted of success by previous private assurances. For the leaders of a national movement to issue invitations broadcast is to court that refusal that casts a blush on our nationhood. We cannot blame that pettiness in a Claude Montefiore which utilizes the occasion to prove that he is bigger than Israel. The business of the Actions Committee was and is to let the delegates take this issue in hand, and for the Congress, if it can accept the English offer, to create a new body for carrying the plans into effect. By a new body we do not mean another appeal in forma pauperis to the I. C. A. The existence of the Hirsch millions is after all a matter of accident, and the future of the Jewish people cannot be made dependable on the existence of even that huge sum of money, and still less upon the whims of the half dozen men who control it. By a new body we mean an organization as independent of the cliques and coteries of official Judaism as the Zionist movement itself, though it will include many, very many, no doubt, who do not share our Zionist inspiration. Herzl's "all the Jews are richer than x—" must stand us ingood stead here. Presuming that the Jewish