The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
211printed page
scan 35 of 54
THE MACCABAEAN
211

A more obvious inducement to failure was the method of selecting members. On the one hand, membership soon became a coveted distinction, and on the other hand the very rigidity that made it a distinction could not be maintained. Promises of holding to its exalted standard in many cases had to be taken in lieu of proof of past allegiance to the standard. The great and the good could not be discriminated against if they were found wanting, let us say, in a knowledge of Hebrew, especially if they sought membership with disinterested zeal. Of one excellent would-be-member, who never got beyond the stage of candidacy, it is told that on the morning after he knew a meeting of the Odessa Lishkah had taken place, he was in the habit of drawing forth his check book and saying to his associate in business, who enjoyed membership in the B'nai Mosheh: "Well, how much will it cost me to-day?" Unable to gain entrance into the charmed circle, he held it a privilege to contribute of his means to the admirable projects he was convinced had been evolved at any given meeting.

Whatever the reasons for failure—and they cannot be recounted here any more than the whole tale of achievements can be told—the beneficent effects and influences, and they are many, are with us still, and all of them are traceable to the appeal here translated. As was said in the beginning, "The Way of Life" remains to this day the programme of Jewish nationalism, of that Zionism which is at once spiritual, philanthropic, and political, and in good time, when the hope of "ultimate victory" is about to be realized, will be also diplomatic.

H. S.

* * * * *

1. The vicissitudes of Israel throughout the centuries of the Dispersion, but

particularly during these latter days of ours, make it plain that we Jews cannot hope to lead the life of a separate nation among strange peoples, and yet be as one of them; taking part in all the activities about us as though we were full-blooded natives of the lands of our sojourn, and at the same time remain a nation peculiar in views and distinct in character. Woe unto us in evil days and woe unto us in days of sunshine! Misfortunes maim our manhood, favorable circumstances our national spirit. The former make of us men despicable in the sight of our fellows, the latter a nation despicable in its own sight. In vain for us to waste our strength and dissipate our means, in the effort to conquer an unassailable position in the midst of another nation. We are bound to fail. Two paths lie stretched out before us: the path of life and the path of death. If our eyes are fixed upon the death goal, then let us disregard the counsel of temporizing healers, let us await death with a calm spirit. It may tarry and delay, but come it inevitably must. If, however, we choose life, then it behooves us to build us a house for ourselves alone, and in a secure spot,—and can there be any spot securer than the land inherited from our fathers?—then it behooves us to consecrate our noblest powers, material and spiritual, to the one purpose, the regeneration of our people in the land of our forefathers.

2. Whether our feeble powers suflice to attain so diffieult, so remote a goal? Where is the man wise enough to give an answer, clear and incontrovertible, to this question? How often have not sympathizers and adversaries vainly striven with each other to reach a conclusion sanctioned by logie and precedent? However. beyond the limits of the intelleet and reasoning there lies a vast and powerful realm whose name is faith, and in all the disputes between the nationalists and