Steps were taken to seek members outside of Odessa. A field-agent, Joshua Eisenstadt, was employed to go about among the intelligent Jews of Russia, and observe likely candidates until he was assured of their fitness. The qualities required of members were intelligence, Jewish knowledge, especially acquaintance with the Hebrew language, a character above suspicion, stout courage, and unselfish devotion in the widest sense to the nationalist ideal in the largest sense. Chevaliers of nationalism they were to be, sans peur et sans reproche. Lodges, called Lishkot, were formed in many cities of Russia, and the society had members in Palestine and Great Britain, in Paris and Berlin, yet the whole number of members never went beyond four times the thirty-six righteous of Jewish tradition, who all looked for direction first to Odessa as a centre, then to Warsaw, and finally to Palestine.
Results? Yes, there were practical results. Take, for instance, the Warsaw Lishkah. In their capacity as B'nai Mosheh, its members formed the societies that established respectively the colony Rehobot in Palestine, one of the most flourishing of the Palestinian colonies; the Carmel Wine Company, and the prolific publication society called Achiassof. To the influence of the B'nai Mosheh is due also the establishment of the Hebrew magazine Ha-Shiloah, and of the famous school in Jaffa, to which abundant support was granted so long as it was conducted in the nationalist spirit and with pedagogic ability. And when their centre was transferred to Palestine, the B'nai Mosheh performed a most important service in issuing a monthly bulletin, called "Letters from the Land of Israel," dealing with physical and spiritual conditions in the Holy Land, with Turkish laws re-
garding the acquisition of land, the Jaffa school, and other topics of interest to "lovers of Zion." Of this valuable bulletin, an edition of one hundred and fifty was published, and distributed among the Lishkot of the B'nai Mosheh, and among the most prominent Chobebé Zion.
These are the visible achievements that have attracted wide attention among Jews. Other, subtler results cannot here be traced out. That, as the publishers of the booklet mentioned above say in their introduction to it, must be left to the skill and intimate knowledge of the "One of the People" who, by reason of his ability and tact as a man of affairs, his intense Jewish spirit and philosophy, and his gifts as a writer, was the inspiration and guide of every undertaking.
If success is measured by tenure of life, the B'nai Mosheh was a failure. After three or four years, all the active work was concentrated in the hands of seven or eight members, and soon they carried it on without reference to the organization.
It was a natural result. What "The Way of Life" demands is in the last analysis Jewishness, and Jewishness is not subject to organization nor conditioned upon it. The Jewish bond as such needs no external reinforcement. The members of the B'nai Mosheh, themselves for the most part poor, had to form supplementary organizations for whatever practical purpose they aimed at, and into these their intellectual resources and their physical energy were poured. Their spiritual purposes, on the other hand, could not long brook the restraint of arbitrary regulations. The members, being what they were, were not made that more by becoming B'nai Mosheh.
