The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
203printed page
scan 27 of 54
Facsimile · scan 27 of 54
Scan of p. 203
Text · transcribed from the scan

received us, absorbed us, opened her public schools to us, taught us the lesson, the meaning of her flag. It is now for us to take up her mission and carry on her teaching, her gospel of freedom and light. America has done royally for us; she can not always go on doing in the same full to overflowing measure. It is not even right or best that she should. We must do for ourselves. Over five million of our race are still in bondage, living under the yoke of intolerable conditions, both from within and without—their own dense ignorance, and the horrible despotism around them.

Read the tragic autobiography of Eliakum Zunser, our fellow-Zionist and bard. We can hardly believe that it is actually of our own day, and not the Dark Ages. And we hear what he says about us in America.

“When I look around me and see my Jewish brethren in America, into what giants the hitherto Russian slaves have grown; when I see how my brethren grow, blossom and bring forth good fruit under the bright sun of free America, and when I see how they progress along the road of civilization, culture, art and industry, my eyes fill with tears, and, together with our great prophet, I exclaim:

“For a little moment have I forsaken thee; but with great mercies will I gather thee.”

Dr. Nordau is right when he says that “Zionism’s only hope is in America,” although a Jewish writer, in a recent magazine, would try to prove the contrary, when he gives us the statistics of Zionism in America, as follows: “Of the one hundred and fifty congregations in this land that comprise the liberal, reformed Jewish element, one hundred and forty-five, it is safe to say, are anti-Zionistic both in pul-

pit and pew. The opposition comprises practically all of the reform wing of the synagogue—the modernized, occidentalized and liberal Jews, who, while they do not make up the numerical preponderance, do make up the representative quality of the Jews resident in America.”

The chief mistake this writer makes, I think, is in his classification of "representative Jews in America." I like to quote the saying of a young Russian friend of mine: "When I was in Russia I was a Jew. Now I am an American." My friend was right. One cannot easily be a consistent Jew, whether reform or orthodox, and yet be truly an American in all that the word implies and signifies. Hence we are often accused of clannishness, and the charge is laid against us that we are unable or unwilling to wholly lose ourselves in the community around us. We are always jealously guarding our separate Jewishness, striving to justify and define it by enforced observance, or else we drift helplessly along, caught in popular currents, and our small and inconsequent Jewishness disappears, with nothing left to take its place. Not so with Zionism, however. On the contrary, we can, and we ought to be, Zionists in America, because, like Americanism, Zionism is the democratization of our people, wherein all are made one and equal all nationalities and all shades of belief, conservative, liberal, agnostic, atheistic (if there be any such), all are welcome, and all hold equal rank among us. Sephardim can no longer hold themselves aloof as higher, holier, than the rest of us, and look down loftily upon Ashkenazim. Spanish Jews can no longer despise German Jews, nor German, Russian Jews, and so all along the scale. All the wretched Jewish anti-Semitisms which are so much more con-