The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
195printed page
scan 19 of 54
Facsimile · scan 19 of 54
Scan of p. 195
Text · transcribed from the scan

the Jews into Palestine, they will be given great liberty in the government apart from the conservation of the Sultan's paramount authority.

What is likely to be the character of the inside government of Palestine? The earliest government known to Jews was that of the Patriarchs. That will hardly be re-established. Then there were the Judges, men who gained and held their influence through their ability to lead. That system is too haphazard to be depended upon. Then there came in the monarchy. This was autocratic in principle, though usually weak in reality. It was never very constitutional. In later times reference is made to a great synagogue that seems to have taken the lead during the years of foreign suzerainty. Two thousand years ago the Sanhedrin had taken its place.

The power of the Sanhedrin under Roman rule was at times quite limited. It is hardly probable that any of these forms will be revived. The government of the next Jewish kingdom will be different from anything that it has had before. Dr. Herzl favored what he called an "aristocratic republic." He means by that, government by a certain portion of the people—a noble class who might elect a smaller number to act as their representatives in the government. That would mean that a large part of the people would be considered as the common people, such as the "Third Estate" in France, and would have no voice in the government. France had its own trouble over that. I am inclined to think that such trouble will be avoided in the beginning of the new Jewish nation.

Just what form the government will take it is, of course, impossible to say. It is very probable, however, that these three

characteristics will be present. First, it will be constitutional. To this Dr. Herzl makes reference and indeed makes provision for its being done in his pamphlet, "The Jewish State." This constitution will embody some of the best things not found in constitutions. If so it will be one far advanced. Indeed, I think it likely that it will be in advance of even what Dr. Herzl outlined. Second, the new government will be elective. How broad the franchise will be cannot be said. It is probable that the leaders in the framing of the new laws will come from those nations most advanced along these lines. That would insure the prevalence of the world's best-tried methods. One of the prominent colonies in Palestine to-day is governed by an elective committee of settlers. Again, I think that the new government will be marked by the complete separation of church and state. I am not ignoring the fact that a very large portion of the members of the new kingdom will come from Russia, the stronghold of Orthodoxy. But if the mass of these are given freedom to practise their religion, they will most likely allow others to run the government. Even they have raised no objection, as far as I know, to the Zionist Congress, certainly a modern institution. The separation of church and state is not a new thing in the history of Israel. It has been said of Moses that he kept the functions of the priest and the functions of the magistrate distinct, a radical change from the policy of Egypt where kings were priests. This distinction was long prominent in Jewish policy. It was as late as the time of the Maccabees when the kingly power and priestly power were officially combined. One writer says that in appreciation of the Maccabees the peo-