The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 5 · May 1905
188printed page
scan 12 of 54
Facsimile · scan 12 of 54
Scan of p. 188
Text · transcribed from the scan

and the extent of the triumph of the surrounding influences over the force of heredity will depend upon the relative strength of these forces. The persistence of the hereditary tendency will of course depend largely upon the length of time that the species has had the benefit of unvarying environment, and the extent or degree of the variation to which the type is subjected by the change in environment. These are all fundamental principles governing the origin and development of species, and are equally applicable to the development of civilization, as to the physical characteristics of a species or race.

The application of these principles to what we term the Jewish question is obvious and is necessary, if any understanding is to be arrived at regarding the Jew and his environment. Here is a quotation from Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu which seems to be in exact accordance with these principles: "This work of assimilation by means of dress, language, customs, is progressing everywhere simultaneously, without, however, being equally advanced in all countries, or even among all Jews of the same country." How perfectly does this statement illustrate the struggle of the forces to which I have alluded above. Again in the same chapter: "In England, the Jews who were welcomed by Cromwell, or who landed under the four Georges, are to-day pure Englishmen in manners, habits and feelings." There is much more of the same tenor and tendency, but I have quoted enough to illustrate my point, and we all of us know perfectly that these statements are in the main true.

What I wish to emphasize particularly is, that they are in accord with natural laws, the operation of which is far be-

yond the reach of the individual or the class effected. Individuals subjected to the influences of a changed environment must suffer changes which will bring them into harmony with this environment, and the character of these changes is determined by irresistible forces far above the individuals effected.

In America there appears to be little trace of the Jews as such that were in the country previous to the Revolution, and without investigation as to the facts, I should be prepared to state quite as confidently, as if the matter had been clearly demonstrated by centuries of opportunity, that if the Jews were permitted uniform, free, untrammelled liberty and intercourse with the peoples surrounding them, they would inevitably disappear as a marked and particular racial type. The fact that they have continued so after being for two thousand years scattered among the nations of the earth, and apparently subjected to these modifying influences, is due, I believe, partly to the fact that the initial forces and peculiar characteristics of the type were very marked, and were deep seated by reason of a long period of development under controlling influences tending to produce a strongly individual race and nation; and secondly, it is a matter of fact, that although scattered among the nations of the earth, the Jews have nowhere been freely subject to the influence of their environment to any considerable extent, and only in the last few centuries have a very few Jews, in isolated localities, come under the influence of modifying conditions to a sufficient extent to begin to show an effect. With the broadening tendency of civilization and the consequent increasing freedom of action and intercourse granted to the Jew throughout the world, I regard it as absolutely