The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 4 · April 1905
175printed page
scan 43 of 50

News of the Movement

MOMBASA, British East Africa, March 23. —Major A. St. Hill Gibbons, the African explorer, and his colleagues of the Zionist Commisison, left here to-day for Trieste after an inspection of the territory in East Africa offered by Great Britain for Hebrew colonization. The commission was impressed by the healthfulness of the country, but apparently is not sanguine of the agricultural prospects. The Wanandi tribesmen were unfriendly and attacked the caravan, but were driven off.

VIENNA.

The Action Committee in Vienna announced that it has accepted the resignation of Herr A. H. Reich, Secretary of the Congress Bureau.

British Empire.

LONDON.

A large meeting was held on Sunday, March 5, at the New West End Synagogue, when Mr. Leon Simon, B.A., opened a debate on the question: "Is Anti-Zionism compatible with Judaism?" Mr. Herbert Bentwich, President, was in the Chair. Mr. Simon disclaimed, at the outset, the intention of denying the title of Jew to anybody who wished to be thought a Jew. It would be absurd for Zionists who were at present a minority to claim that only they were really Jews. He wished to regard Judaism, not merely as a matter of personal feeling or practice, but as involving a belief that it was good that Jews should survive as, in some way, a people apart, and a willingness to adopt the course which would best secure their survival. From this point of view the safety of Judaism could not be said to lie in emancipation. The Jews in emancipated countries looked to absorption in their surroundings as an ideal, rather than as a thing to be dreaded. The reason of this longing for death was that they had nothing to live for. Anglo-Jewish thinkers had tried to supply this want by insisting that Israel had a mission. But their "mission" was too vague to stir people, it appealed only to a small section of the race, and it was not specifically Jewish in any real sense. The only ideal which was free

from these defects, and was, therefore, able to preserve the Jewish race, was the national ideal embodied in Zionism. Only by first of all restoring their own unity, and becoming once more a nation, could Jews hope to do any real work in the cause of righteousness and progress.

Mr. Joseph Cowen addressed a public meeting of the West Central Zionist Society on Sunday evening, March 5.

Mr. Cowen said that he would be sorry to think that Zionism stood for Palestine only. Zionism stood for something more than getting the Holy Land; it stood for the moral, spiritual and physical amelioration of the Jews. If he was in favor of having Palestine, that was no reason for disagreeing with others who wanted something else. It was not intended that East Africa should be substituted for Palestine; the desire was for it to be added to Palestine. The task of getting Palestine had been beset with great difficulties, and the chief of these was that Jews was not united on the question. On the day when Jews were agreed on the wish of acquiring the Holy Land, on that day would the Jews get it. It was tolerably certain that if the great majority of the Jews wanted Palestine they could obtain it, and if Zionists, who only formed a small portion of Jewry, were disunited, how could they expect to get it? The business of Zionists was not to allow side-issues which had cropped up to divert them from their path. They must keep a strong front in trying to win over the rest of Jewry to their side.

A meeting of the Executive of the English Zionist Federation was held on Monday, March 6. It was decided not to favor any petty schemes to perpetuate the memory of Dr. Herzl, as they were not only superfluous, but diverted the means and energies of Zionists from the work of the National Tribute. The proposed removal of the Federation offices, the co-option of members, and the question of periodical circulars were discussed, and various applications were considered.

A meeting of the Executive of the English Zionist Federation was held on Monday, March 20.

In view of some discordant pronouncements of individual societies with regard to the East African scheme, it was resolved to define the attitude of the Federation on the subject in a communication to the press.