The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 4 · April 1905
162printed page
scan 32 of 50
162
THE MACCABAEAN

at that Convention which will be the critical meeting in the history of American Zionism. The societies must look at it in that light; proper representation at the convention will justify the existence of the organizations —nothing else.

It is not our business here to decide the policy of that Convention; with its growing feeling for self-guidance the Convention will do that for itself but whatever the program the delegates must be there, and in goodly number. Every society should therefore set its house in order and meet the convention call with every possible enthusiasm. The delegates will come together this time to decide for American Zionism the future of the movement in this country whilst they contribute a vote on the future of the movement as a whole. But it is important that they come together from every city in the country. That is the first thing —let it be done well.

The attention of Zionists who are members of B'nai Brith, the Independent Order of B'nai B'rith is called to an amendment to the preamble of the Order, in which the word "faith" is substituted for "race." This change was made at the New Orleans convention and was unanimously adopted. At this time THE MACCABAEAN does not intend to comment on the meaning of the amendment, for the reason that no explanation has been offered for it. Mr. Simon Wolf, in a letter to the American Hebrew, merely mentions the fact and does not comment upon it, which may be taken to mean that, in his opinion, the substitution of "faith" for "race" is a desirable one. There should be a more explicit declaration than this. The Order includes men who are not in the strict sense members of the

faith, and it includes Zionists who became members on the basis of the old preamble which made the Order a brotherhood of Jews of a common race. If it is the intention of the Order to repudiate the preamble upon which so many Jews found it possible to join it, that declaration should be made at once. As a religious organization for the upliftment of the Jewish people the Order has no standing in the Jewish intercommunal system.

Zangwill's Position, In an interview published in the London Jewish Chronicle Mr. Israel Zang-

will is reported to have said, in answer to the question what should be the attitude of pro-East Africans who are non-Zionists: “I cannot see why they do not join the ranks solely on the East African issue with a view to smashing the opposition party.”

In the course of the same interview, Mr. Zangwill complains of the unconstitutional policy of the Actions Comite, but his mouth must now close on all such matters for in the above statement he does nothing less than invite the opposition to come into the Zionist ranks in order to smash the movement. Zangwill probably forgot when he saw this that he is an organization man, an officer of the movement and not a free lance, and that therefore, he had no right to say such a thing even if he thought it. But this is in the nature of the man and there are others in the same position who fail to recognize that office carries with it circumspection of opinion, a matter of greater importance than any other form of responsibility. No doubt there are those who are at once ready to drum Zangwill out of the movement for this and similar utterances; in fact it is possible,