The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
118printed page
scan 36 of 52
118
THE MACCABAEAN

The Maccabæan

Editorial Pages. J. de Haas, Editor.
MARCH, 1905.

From the official report A Personal of the last meeting of the Note. Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists, it will be seen that the editor of the MACCABAEAN has resigned the office of Secretary of the organization. The circumstances involving that resignation have been fully dealt with in a circular issued to the Societies on February 28, and there can be no doubt but that the appointment of Dr. Magnes to the temporary Hon. Secretaryship will be beneficial to the cause. My resignation means no change of attitude, merely a change of position, which I hope will eventually enable me, by the decrease of detail work, to devote myself more and more to the larger issues of the movement. I heartily thank all correspondents for their good wishes. J. de H.]

As the Seventh Congress The Next draws near, the air resounds Congress more and more with the alarms and excursions of divergent policies. A certain recrudescence of the old Chovevi Zion idea has manifested itself. All those who are Palestinean Zionists, as it is the fashion to describe some of us, but are in doubt as to the future political possibilities of our movement, are leaning towards this old form of Zionism.

A return to Chovevi Zionism would be a weakness on our part. That policy was not abandoned because of Herzl, rather it had failed just prior to his issue of the Jewish State. Chovevi Zionism itself

was a relapse from the earlier idea of a nationalized Jewry. It was the achievement of the "do something politicians," who now again, fretful and fearful, are willing to turn from large measures and great ideas to the ways and thoughts of Little Peddlington. Every Zionist must grasp the theories that condition our movement. We have created a world-wide movement in order to arrive at a political status for our people. Our national idea demands a complete national life for us, our historical sentiments link us to Palestine. Our object, therefore, is to create a national state in Palestine. Any one political policy may fail us in the attempt to achieve this; we must then turn to another, but it must be political, for only a national policy can give us that larger measure of life which we seek and need. The mere adoption of a political attitude, independent of its success, means some enfranchisement for us as a people, it gives us strength and courage, and it is this quality which has made Zionism what it is.

Uudoubtedly, the so-called practical Zionists of the Chovevi Zion type can show, and would show, “something” in the way of definite results, but such results are nothing more than experiments in eolonization.

Chovevi Zion means infiltration into Palestine. No state can be built that way. However prosperous the settlements may be they remain settlements, for we cannot look forward to such an internal upheaval in Palestine as shall breathe spirit of national life into the Jewish colonies, and compel them to take upon themselves a political status. No doubt many Jews think that way, and the wish is father to the thought, but it is not the kind of wish in which we desire to indulge.

Zionism is Jewish progress, that is, it