Mr. Marshall's Letter to Dr. Funk
THE gentlemen who have petitioned for the removal of Melvil Dewey, New York State Librarian, have been informed of the official rebuke of Mr. Dewey by the Board of Regents. The Board of Regents did not enter into the merits of the case, but on general principles decided that a state official should not be engaged in any business which offended so large and influential a body of citizens. One of the noteworthy incidents of this affair was the correspondence which arose between Dr. Isaac Funk, publisher of the Jewish Encyclopedia, and Mr. Louis Marshall, the well-known lawyer. Mr. Marshall, from all reports, is not a Zionist; for that reason we present his letter in full in order to give our readers a new sensation, a non-Zionist, standing manfully for the dignified and daring response of the Jewish people to anti-Semitism. Mr. Zangwill has recently said that the petitioners for the removal of Mr. Dewey are not anti-Zionists, but ante-Zionists, they are on the threshold to Zionism. The letter appears in full, also, as an illustration of the growing fear on the part of many that this prejudice is no accidental manifestation.
Mr. Marshall's Letter
My dear sir—After maturely reflecting upon the contents of yours of the 8th inst., relating to the pending proceedings for the removal of Mr. Melvil Dewey from the office of state librarian, I believe it to be important to exchange my views, for those which you have expressed.
First of all, let me say, that there is but a single question to be considered, whether the removal of Mr. Dewey will be resented by a few or by many, not whether it will result in stirring up deep feeling, or engendering bitterness; not whether it will drive ill-concealed or even latent prejudice from his lair, but whether Mr. Dewey has, as a public official, forfeited his claim to hold the important place in our state edu-
cational system, which he now occupies. Your letter is silent on the subject; you do not attempt to justify his act; you do not deny, or palliate the accusation; you do not attempt to argue that a paid official of the state, may, while he is drawing a salary out of the state treasury, to which Jews as well as Christians contribute, disseminate documents of anti-Semitic tendencies, which tend to foster race and religious prejudice, and consign even the most worthy and the most excellent (such is Mr. Dewey's phase), to contempt, obloquy and animadversion. It is to your credit that your friendship for the accused has not led you to champion his utterances.
You are evidently misinformed as to the facts since you assume that the only evidence against Mr. Dewey is to be found in what you are pleased to term "decoy letters." Should you have heard his testimony before the committee, and noted his admissions, and his failures to deny, what if it had been otherwise than truth he would have hastened to deny, you would have been discreetly publicated on the subject. Hence we fear no publication of the testimony; on the contrary, we welcome it. If Mr. Dewey can afford to appear in public, arrayed in the garb in which he has attired himself, we may, with entire equanimity, behold the edifying spectacle.
We have no grievance against Mr. Dewey, as Mr. Dewey. We are not concerned with his official shortcomings, which have been thrust upon our attention by those eager to disclose him. On the contrary, we have consistently refused to consider them, be they as Pelion piled on Ossa. We are not actuated by spite, or by a desire for vengeance. We seek but justice, and the establishment of what to us seems to be a vital principle, underlying our entire system of government,—the equality of all citizens who officially administer it.
But we are warned, nay, threatened, that if we persist in our attempt to obtain public recognition of these principles, which theo-