The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
112printed page
scan 30 of 52
Facsimile · scan 30 of 52
Scan of p. 112
Text · transcribed from the scan

at the same time, I urge you to be ready. The Palestine question must be raised some day, and then European statesmen will enquire what claim you have. Will you be able to answer that you are the inhabitants of the country? If you do not set up a claim, someone else will try and obtain the land for themselves. Zionism must be established in Jerusalem, and you must not quarrel, or the whole movement will come to grief. I remember that not so very long ago the whole of the British Empire was governed by a Jew. If a man of that ability could be found who could govern a people not his own, and govern a particularly stubborn people such as the English, I do not see why it should be impossible for the Jews to govern a country not larger than Wales. I would not press for autonomy at the present time. Whatever money there is, whatever enthusiasm and desire to work there is, I would attempt to turn the whole of it into Palestine. You should not make any distinctions, but you should help everyone in Palestine. You should make the movement something that will unite you together into a single nation. I would not confine myself to agricultural

colonization, but all poor Jews should be helped to earn a living in Palestine. And I would take the young people and bring them up in useful handicrafts or agriculture, so that, in time, you may become the dominant people in Palestine. I think I have said everything I can suggest on this subject. Your claim to the country will be the amount of work you have done. It is no use talking and no use making speeches and holding meetings; what is wanted is work. If nothing is done the movement will die out, but if a steady attempt is made to lay the foundations of the future, I think Zionism, whose development I have watched from the beginning, will grow into a fact. I have only one word to say in conclusion. I most sincerely believe that in the time of this present generation one of two things will happen. Either you will become a people, scattered, no doubt, over the whole surface of the world, but with a home you can turn to as the home of the race, or you will be swallowed up in the nations amongst whom you dwell, and there will be no Israel at all.

Ideals of Zionism

By Dr. Harry Friedenwald

ZIONISM has been discussed by so many and from so many sides, it has been viewed from every point of preconceived prejudice of opponent and of partial sympathy of adherent, that it should not surprise us that confusion and error and misrepresentation exist in the minds of many, even among intelligent classes. The purposes and ideals of our movement are not understood. Men still address Jewish

audiences, inveighing against Zionism as though its sole purpose and aim were escape from anti-Semitism; or you hear it described as a scheme for colonizing poor Jews!

We must distinguish between the Jews as individuals scattered here and there throughout the world, and the Jewish people as a whole. This whole is made up of its many parts, but it is more than an