The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
111printed page
scan 29 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN
111

There may be statesmen who say you had very much better leave it alone, and not raise this Palestinian question. It is a very awkward question, but leaving things alone generally makes all the more trouble in the long run. The formation of the Lebanon province was one of the things which induced me to think that a Jewish province might also be formed in Palestine. The gradual dismemberment of the Turkish Empire in Europe must have some influence in the immediate future on the West of Asia. One cannot foresee what in a few years' time may be the result of the great events happening in Russia. There is a very practical reason why the Russians must always take an interest in Palestine. From their Trans-Caucasian provinces the shortest route to the Mediterranean leads through Palestine. They have worked for years towards acquiring the Holy Land for themselves. As to Germany, I do not think that the interests of that country and His Majesty the Emperor are other than religious, and I do not perceive any intention on the part of Germany to get hold of the country. Since the days of Napoleon's conquest of Palestine, and the days of Napoleon III., who sent troops after the massacres of Damascus, the French have always cherished the idea of a possible reversion of Palestine to themselves. England cannot be entirely indifferent to the subject of Palestine, because it is next door to Egypt and the Suez Canal. We cannot tell, therefore, what the history of the future may be, all these nations being equally interested in Palestine. It seems to me that the solution of these rivalries and ambitions consists in the neutralisation of Palestine, which should be made into a West Asian Switzerland; but a West Asian Switzerland must have a population; and who have more right to the country than the ancient race to which it belonged?

It is no use, however, blinking the diffieulties that stand in the way; we must acknowledge the diflieulties and understand them. There is no doubt that the Turks are the main diffieulty. His Majesty the Sultan is a sincere Mohammedan, and not only the political ruler of a large empire, which extends to the boundariesof Persia, but the head of the Mohammedan religion, the Khalif and successor of Mohammed. He is acknowledged as such by nearly all the Mohammedans in the world. The Khalif is supposed to be in possession of the sanctuaries of Mecca and Jerusalem, and as long as the Sultan remains the head of Western Islam and the ruler of his Empire, he has avery particular reason for wishing to retain Jerusalem. I think that if you go to him in the first instance, and say, “We wish to form an autonomous province in Palestine,” the Sultan will say politely, “Do you?” And if you offer to buy Palestine he will reply, like Naboth, and he is not inclined to sell the inheritance of his fathers. You must look at things from the Sultan’s point of view, and if he will not give you permission to set up an autonomous State in Palestine, you are not in a position to force him to do so. But you should also remember history, and if you have to deal with a Nebuchadnezzar to-day you may have to deal with a Cyrus to-morrow. One cannot tell what may happen in the Turkish Empire. In the present cireum- stances you should leave His Majesty the Sultan alone for the moment. You should convince him that the movement is a perfeetly straightforward and honest movement. It is not intended to go in for any political intrigue. You are not so foolish as to suppose you can hoodwink the Sultan, because you know perfectly well he is a very able man, and informs himself on every subject that concerns his interests and those of his empire. But,